Something You Should Know
Why Rituals Exist Everywhere & The Exercise Paradox - SYSK Choice
Sat, 28 Dec 2024
We know that smiling is a universal human expression of happiness. Everyone smiles - in fact, even babies born blind smile. What is the purpose of smiling? So, what does smiling do for you? Why are we attracted to a person’s smile? Listen as I begin this episode with a brief look at smiling. https://www.livescience.com/5254-smiles-innate-learned.html We have all kinds of rituals. There are religious rituals, family rituals, holidays rituals, personal rituals – rituals are everywhere. By definition, rituals don’t actually do anything really. They are just rituals. So why do we have them at all? It appears we have them because they are important and necessary according to my guest, Dimitris Xygalatas. He is an anthropologist and cognitive scientist who runs the Experimental Anthropology Lab at the University of Connecticut. He is also author of the book Ritual: How Seemingly Senseless Acts Make Life Worth Living (https://amzn.to/3Pq7U4b). We all know exercise is important for our health. Still, a lot of people hate it. Why is something so vital to human health so despised and avoided by so many? Maybe we never really evolved to exercise – at least not the way exercise is done today. This is according to Daniel E. Lieberman. Daniel is a professor of biological sciences and a professor of the Department of Human Evolutionary Biology at Harvard University. He is also the author of the book Exercised: Why Something We Never Evolved to Do Is Healthy and Rewarding (https://amzn.to/3hoPQea). Listen and you’ll never again feel guilty the next time you decide you really DON’T want to go out and exercise. Salt is bad for your blood pressure – that is common knowledge. But is it true? Does eating salt actually elevate blood pressure and does reducing salt help to lower it? Listen as I reveal some of the science regarding salt and blood pressure and why potassium is also an important player in this story. https://healthyeating.sfgate.com/relationships-between-salt-potassium-6609.html PLEASE SUPPORT OUR SPONSORS!!! INDEED: Get a $75 SPONSORED JOB CREDIT to get your jobs more visibility at https://Indeed.com/SOMETHING Support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Terms & conditions apply. AURA: Save on the perfect gift by visiting https://AuraFrames.com to get $35-off Aura’s best-selling Carver Mat frames by using promo code SOMETHING at checkout! SHOPIFY: Sign up for a $1 per-month trial period at https://Shopify.com/sysk . Go to SHOPIFY.com/sysk to grow your business – no matter what stage you’re in! MINT MOBILE: Cut your wireless bill to $15 a month at https://MintMobile.com/something! $45 upfront payment required (equivalent to $15/mo.). New customers on first 3 month plan only. Additional taxes, fees, & restrictions apply. HERS: Hers is changing women's healthcare by providing access to GLP-1 weekly injections with the same active ingredient as Ozempic and Wegovy, as well as oral medication kits. Start your free online visit today at https://forhers.com/sysk DELL: It's your last chance to snag Dell Technologies’ lowest prices of the year before the holidays! If you've been waiting for an AI-ready PC, this is their biggest sale of the year! Shop now at https://Dell.com/deals PROGRESSIVE: The Name Your Price tool from Progressive can help you save on car insurance! You just tell Progressive what you want to pay and get options within your budget. Try it today at https://Progressive.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
what is that smell? I am definitely getting a hint of a deal. Oh wait, it's more than a hint. Yeah, these are the best deals and not just this season, but all year long. In all seriousness, the smartest shoppers know that you get the brands you love with the most savings and cash back with Rakuten. And I know I'm certainly interested in sniffing out those deals.
Start getting cash back at your favorite stores like Urban Outfitters,
petco even expedia and getting cash back doesn't mean you have to miss out on sales because those can be stacked right on top it's easy to use and based on a simple idea stores pay rakuten for sending them shoppers and rakuten shares the money with you as cash back through paypal or check smells like a perfect deal to me download the free rakuten app and never miss a deal or go to rakuten.com to start getting the most bang for your buck that's r-a-k-u-t-e-n
Today on Something You Should Know, being happy certainly makes you smile, but does smiling make you happy? Then, rituals. We all have them. They don't really do anything, but they're so important. In fact...
As far as we know, there is no culture, whether past or present, that has no rituals. In fact, when we look at our own cultures, we will see that the most important moments of our lives, like birthdays and weddings, all of these moments are shrouded in ritual.
Also, does eating salt really raise your blood pressure? And the science of exercise. The benefits are greater than you may realize.
We focus too much on weight. I think, you know, your health is what really matters. And there's so many other benefits of just being fit. And so even if you're not losing weight, you're still getting all kinds of wonderful benefits.
All this today on Something You Should Know. Every time I've had to hire someone, it had to be done fast. But as I've discovered anyway, hiring can be very time-consuming, and even still there are no guarantees. Which is why when it comes to hiring, Indeed is all you need. Right? The trick to finding the right person is to make sure a lot of qualified people know about your job opening.
And you see, Indeed has this thing called Sponsored Jobs. So your post jumps to the top of the page for relevant candidates. So you can reach the people you want to reach faster. And it works. Now here's what I think is the magic of Indeed.
They take this process of hiring, which is something you probably don't do a lot or feel really skilled at, and they guide you through it so you end up with the right person for the job quickly. Plus, with Indeed-sponsored jobs, there are no monthly subscriptions, no long-term contracts. You only pay for results. There's no need to wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed.
And listeners of this show get a $75 sponsored job credit to get your jobs more visibility at Indeed.com slash something. Just go to Indeed.com slash something right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash something. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring? Indeed is all you need.
Something you should know. Fascinating intel. The world's top experts. And practical advice you can use in your life. Today, Something You Should Know with Mike Carruthers.
Hi, and welcome to Something You Should Know. We start today with a question. Does smiling make you happier, or does being happy make you smile? Well, clearly being happy makes you smile, but smiling, according to the latest research, might make you a little bit happier, but it's not going to make you a lot happier. Here's what we do know about smiling. Everybody smiles. It is universal.
People are born with the ability to smile. They don't copy the expression. Even babies who are born blind smile. Women smile more than men. Younger people smile more than older people. Males with high testosterone smile least of all. A smiling person is judged to be more pleasant, attractive, sincere, sociable, and competent than a non-smiling person.
Babies reserve a special smile for family members and a newborn baby shows a preference for a smiling face over a non-smiling face. And that is something you should know. I guess we all have little rituals we take part in. Around the holidays, there are millions of rituals. But all year long, we participate in rituals because, well, actually, I'm not sure why we participate in rituals.
I guess it makes us feel good, but there has to be more to it than that. So let's find out why this apparently universal practice of rituals seems ingrained in so much of human behavior. And here to discuss it is Dimitris Zigalatis. He is an anthropologist and cognitive scientist who runs the Experimental Anthropology Lab at the University of Connecticut.
He's author of a book called Ritual, How Seemingly Senseless Acts Make Life Worth Living. Hi, Dimitris. Welcome to Something You Should Know.
Hi, it's a pleasure to be with you.
So what is a ritual as you study it and define it? What is it?
Rituals are regularly repeated sets of actions that feel special. They're not ordinary. And yet they have either no stated goal or even when they do have a goal, that goal is not causally related to the actions themselves. I like to give the example of brushing your teeth, which is not a ritual.
And the reason it's not a ritual is that it has a very specific purpose and the actions we undertake to achieve that purpose are causally related. So I move my brush up and down and that helps me remove food from my teeth, helping me
make them clean now if i woke up every morning and i and i waved my toothbrush in the air with the belief that this will help me clean my teeth or for that matter with without any belief at all now that would be an example of a ritual so it's really it's really something that does nothing and yet it has meaning anyway Exactly.
And that's why it's such a fascinating topic to study, because people consider their rituals deeply meaningful, and they put a lot of time, resources and effort into those rituals. Some of the rituals that I studied even involve very painful, even excruciating things like walking on fire, having your body pierced with needles and skewers.
And people consider these rituals very, very important in their lives. And yet, when I ask them why they perform these rituals, and I've asked hundreds, if not thousands of people that question, they have a very hard time explaining why they're important. Most of the time, they'll just look at me and they'll go, what do you mean? These are our traditions. That's what we do. That's who we are.
Does everyone or at least every culture have rituals? Has there ever been a culture that just didn't have any?
As far as we know, there is no culture, whether past or present, that has no rituals. In fact, when we look at our own cultures, we will see that the most important moments of our lives, whether these are personal moments, like birthdays and weddings, or collective moments, like presidential inaugurations. All of these moments are shrouded in ritual.
Why is it so universal? If in fact rituals don't really do anything, why are they so important to everybody?
This is the big question that my research has been asking. Now, anthropologists have long pointed out that rituals... although they have no practical impact on the world, that is not to say that they have no impact at all. So they've pointed out that rituals can have important psychological and social effects. But these theories remained untested for a very long time.
And it's only in recent years that we were able to put them to the test and bring scientific measurements into anthropological research in order to be able to understand what these rituals actually do for us. And what we're finding out is that they can play very important functions for us.
They help us find comfort, help us find connection and meaning in life, and they help shape our sense of who we are as a person and as a member of the various groups that we belong to.
There are rituals, though, that I can think of, pretty benign rituals, but rituals nonetheless of, you know, rubbing a rabbit's foot or, you know, for good luck kind of thing. And it doesn't work, yet people still do it. And if it did work, then it wouldn't be a ritual, would it?
True. But even those actions that seem utterly pointless... we are finding that they might have important functions as well, important psychological functions. For example, you mentioned good luck rituals.
We're finding that if you were to search for places or situations in which individual ritualization takes place, things like superstitions, for example, the best place to look for that would be things like a casino or a sports stadium or perhaps a hospital or war zones.
all of these situations that's where we see that people spontaneously engage in all of those ritualized actions and what all of these situations have in common is that they involve a lot of uncertainty and a lot of anxiety so anthropologists have theorized a long time ago that perhaps engaging in rituals is an attempt to overcome this anxiety now how exactly this works we didn't know recent research provides evidence about how this exactly might work
And that evidence is?
For example, in my own research that I've done with my colleagues, when we bring people into a lab and we stress them up, we see that their behavior becomes more ritualized. Their movements become more repetitive. And we take this research into the real world and we go into religious temples and we measure people's anxiety before and after they perform their cultural rituals.
And we see that performing those rituals helps them reduce anxiety. We can see this in their heart rate variability, in their cortisol levels, and even at the subjective level, they feel calmer. How does that exactly happen?
In other studies in the laboratory, we see that when people engage in those repetitive movements that are very common in rituals, even if they're stripped of any kind of meaning, that in itself helps them deal with anxiety. And the reason for that is that it is related to the way our brain works. Our brain doesn't just passively absorb stimuli.
It makes active predictions about the state of the world all of the time. Before I even finish the sentence that I'm about to say, you have certain expectations about what's going to follow. Our brain does this in all kinds of domains. And when we don't have this ability to make predictions, when we don't know what's about to come, that's when we feel stressed.
And that's where ritual comes in, because if ritual is anything, it is structure. It is order. Ritual is very predictable. When we engage in a familiar ritual, we know exactly what's going to happen. We know exactly when it is going to happen, and we know exactly how it's going to happen. And this gives our brain a sense of control.
And it doesn't really matter whether this sense of control is real or illusory. All that matters is that it actually works. And this is what we're finding in our studies. People who engage in those repetitive rituals, they're better able to cope with anxiety.
But you mentioned at the beginning here that you study rituals of cultures that do incredibly painful things as rituals. How does that help your anxiety? Seems like if you came at me with a needle, I don't think I'd be less anxious. I'd be more anxious.
That is an excellent point. In fact, some of the rituals that I've studied, they involve unbearable pain. Some of the ceremonies that are studied on the island of Mauritius, for example, they are Hindu ceremonies that involve piercing the body with hundreds of needles and even skewers and rods through the cheeks and walking barefooted on the burning asphalt under the midsummer tropical sun.
And all that is happening as people are carrying these very large shrines that can weigh 100 pounds. And when they reach their destination, which is six hours later, they have to climb this hill carrying these burdens up to the top of the hill where the Temple of Muruga lies. So this is really a full day of self-imposed torture.
And even in this context, we have done studies that show that they might offer tangible benefits to those people who do them. So in the context of these rituals, we look at people's physiological reactions. And of course, we see that during that day, they're extremely stressed, orders of magnitude more stressed than they would be in their everyday life.
And we see this in things like their electrodermal activity, so their skin conductance, which is a measure of stress. Now, when we measure the health outcomes of those rituals, we see that a month later, those who have engaged in those rituals, they have better subjective wellbeing and quality of life than those who didn't.
And within the group that does the ritual, we see that the more they suffer on the day, the more pronounced these effects.
Is there any indication, though, that someone who, say, pierces themselves with sharp needles or walks on hot coals and does these very painful things, that they get more of an internal benefit from those rituals because they're so painful and involved? compared to someone who just, you know, rubs a rabbit's foot because that's their ritual?
Or can you get the same from any ritual if you believe you get the same from any ritual?
Yes, and here's where meaning comes in. We know from psychological research that we intuitively attribute meaning to effort. So if you think of some of the moments in our lives that we consider to be the most important to us, and those are the things that fundamentally shaped us as a person. So they changed our personal autobiographical narrative.
Those moments will very often include times of suffering. the time perhaps we climbed a mountain or the time a woman might have given birth, the time we survived a car accident, even some of these traumatic moments, we come to consider them significant in our personal narrative. We attribute meaning to them. And the fact that rituals involve
This type of suffering that, at least in the rituals that I study, is self-imposed. So the fact that you chose to do this ritual, the fact that you chose to put so much effort into it, also makes it a much more meaningful experience in our mind and in our memory.
Rituals is our topic today, and I'm speaking with Dimitris Zigalatis. He is an anthropologist and author of the book Ritual, How Seemingly Senseless Acts Make Life Worth Living. Dell Technologies is celebrating with anniversary savings on their most popular tech. For a limited time only, save on select next-gen PCs, like the XPS 16 powered by Intel Core Ultra processors, and more.
Unleash more possibilities with cutting-edge systems, our most advanced features, and great prices. Plus, curate your dream setup with deals on select monitors, mice, and more must-have electronics and accessories. When you shop online at dell.com slash deals, you'll have access to state-of-the-art technology to match your forward-thinking spirit and free shipping on everything.
Anniversary savings await you for a limited time only at Dell.com slash deals. That's Dell.com slash deals. I really love it when I find a great new podcast. And then, of course, I have to share that with everyone. And what I really want you to listen to is Curiosity Weekly. Curiosity Weekly from Discovery makes sense of some of the biggest questions and ideas shaping our world.
It's all about new discoveries happening in science and tech. They have expert guests that make it all make sense. It's a bit similar to Something You Should Know, which is why I think you'll like it, but it takes a different spin.
Listen to Curiosity Weekly and you'll discover things like how neuroscientists are studying TikTok and social media habits to see which chemicals are being released in your brain that make you so obsessed. Or how it is that you can fly from Florida to England on a plane using recycled plastic jet fuel. And how AI can now read hieroglyphics from Egyptian pyramids.
What's so great about Curiosity Weekly is there's so much to learn about science and tech, and these guys seem to have their finger on the pulse of the most interesting stuff. Food science, the science behind social media, the science of algorithms, computer science, and it's all explained in a fascinating way every week on Curiosity Weekly.
Listen to Curiosity Weekly wherever you get your podcasts. So, Demetrius, in these cultures where they engage in these elaborate rituals that are very painful, doesn't anyone ever stop and go, hey, wait a minute. Wait, why are we doing this? Couldn't we do something else that's perhaps a little less painful? Or do they just, we just do it. It's just what we do.
That's what people say when I ask them why they perform their rituals. The most common answer I get is just what we do. So as human beings, we tend to do as the Romans do. This is very important for us because we are a hypersocial species. So most of the things we learn in life, they actually come from other people, whether it's through intentional instruction or just by observing them.
So we have evolved to to imitate what others around us do and especially imitate what people of our group do and particularly influential individuals in that group. So if everybody in your group does it, if the most prestigious individuals in your group do it, then you end up doing it as well. And by doing this, you also reap the benefits of doing it.
We see, for example, that people who engage in very painful rituals, that gives a boost in their reputation. So there are studies conducted in India by an anthropologist called Ellie Power, and she's finding that performing these very painful rituals just once a year is the equivalent of going to the temple every single week in terms of how you're perceived by others.
People who perform these rituals more frequently or who pay a higher price to perform them, they are seen as more trustworthy. They're better able to call upon others when they need things like borrowing money or help with taking care of their children and so on and so forth. So those social benefits are very real.
But those social benefits are not why they do it. Or is it?
At least it seems that at a reflective conscious level, they are not why they do it. So people, even as people recognize that by taking part in that ritual, you feel bonded with each other. I don't think anybody has ever told me, I do this ritual to boost my status. Now, at the back of people's head, that might be there, of course.
And at some level, we're conscious that by virtue of engaging in those rituals, that changes the way people see us. But I don't think that's the primary motivation. I think the primary motivation is just to fit in.
Well, getting away from the painful rituals, because we don't really have a whole lot of those here in the West. I mean, it doesn't seem like that's all that popular.
That our rituals tend to be much more benign and, you know, like... And this time of year, Christmas has a lot of rituals where people do things and decorate in certain ways that they don't do any other time of year because it's Christmas and they do it... because that's what we do, but also because I think it makes people feel good.
Absolutely. I tend to see rituals as social technologies. They are successful social technologies because they're able to harness all kinds of different mechanisms, the psychological mechanisms. So it is not just pain and suffering that they can recruit in order to make an occasion seem special. They can recruit things like emotional arousal. They can recruit things like sensory pageantry.
And that's what you see with holiday celebrations. They're bursting with pageantry. They're full of colors and smells and sometimes literally bells and whistles. So they stimulate all of your senses. And because the most important moments of our lives are related to extravagant ceremonies, weddings, graduation ceremonies, birthday parties.
Whenever we see an extravagant ceremony immediately in our brain, that signals that this is an important moment. And this is an important moment. This is a moment to pay attention to. This is a moment to look forward to. This is a moment to fully embrace.
Is there any sense that rituals are on the rise or on the decline or it's pretty steady or does it go in waves or anything like that?
The way I see it is that ritual has always been part of our nature and it's just as much a part of our nature today as it has always been. Sometimes we might get the sense that ritual is in decline just because in parts of the world, in the West in particular, we see that membership in at least the major religious organizations is declining.
But that is not to say that people are abandoning ritual altogether. In fact, what I see is that the more people
stop performing some of the more traditional rituals perhaps related to to the church in the american setting the more they seek the same kinds of experiences in other domains of life so you can find collective rituals for example in the context of musical concerts or sports stadiums or events like burning man or coachella You can find them in politics.
You can find them in all of our secular institutions. You can find them in the courtroom. You can find them in university graduation ceremonies and so on and so forth. So ritual has always been there and it's still there. The context in which it is performed might often change, but our need for ritual remains the same.
And so many of those rituals that you just mentioned in the courtroom and at graduation, I'm thinking of those kind of things that, you know, why do we do them? Well, that's just what we do. It's just part of the ceremony. It's part of the pageantry. It's just what we do. Like you're almost not supposed to question it.
That is true. That is what it feels like to people. We're not supposed to question certain traditions. And ritual traditions are particularly the kinds of traditions that feel this way. There are studies that actually show that when you suggest to people that certain of their most ritualized public holidays, things like Thanksgiving,
If you were to change those holidays, people get morally appalled by this. They find this offensive that somebody would suggest making changes to those rituals. They're not supposed to change, even as they do change, because Thanksgiving actually in the past was moved. It was moved by a week earlier so that the holiday period would be extended and people would spend more money.
And people didn't like that.
People didn't like that. Most states actually refused to enforce this. And recently, so now nobody remembers this anymore. But recently there was a study that asked people this question. How would you feel if the government wanted to move Thanksgiving by a week? And people really felt that this would be offensive.
You know, as you're talking, I'm thinking, you know, back to 2020 when we were all locked down. And one of the things that happened was that for the class of 2020 at every grade level, at every school, there was no graduation. And people were talking about that, that how sorry we felt for members of the class of 2020 because there would be no graduation. Graduation, which is just a ritual.
It doesn't do anything other than recognize a passage in life. But people felt really bad about that because graduation is so important.
It's very important, and we know this. We've all heard people, at least I've heard people say that because their university didn't have a graduation ceremony, they felt that their degree was diminished. And we saw people go to great lengths to offer this ritual experience to the students.
So in India, there was a university that created avatars for every student and had a virtual ceremony and invited... famous guest speakers for the commencement address, and they had their own avatars.
In other parts of the world, we saw that schools might have socially distant graduation ceremonies in all sorts of innovative ways, including somewhere a ski lift so they could maintain social distance. So our institutions recognize this need for ritual.
Well, after listening to you, I think it's clear we all recognize that need for ritual. It's important to all of us to one degree or another. Dimitris Zigalatis has been my guest. He is an anthropologist and cognitive scientist who runs the Experimental Anthropology Lab at the University of Connecticut. And the name of his book is Ritual, How Seemingly Senseless Acts Make Life Worth Living.
And there's a link to that book in the show notes. Thanks, Dimitris.
Thank you, Mike. It's been a real pleasure.
Think about all the online businesses selling products, ones that you probably buy. Mattel, Gymshark, Untuckit, Magic Spoon, all solid businesses. But a key ingredient to any successful online business is the business behind the business that makes the whole selling and checkout process work. And for millions of businesses, that business is Shopify.
Shopify is the number one checkout on the planet. And the not-so-secret secret is something they have called ShopPay that boosts conversions up to 50%, meaning way less carts going abandoned and way more sales going... So if you're into growing your business, your commerce platform better be ready to sell wherever your customers are scrolling or strolling.
On the web, in your store, in their feed, and everywhere in between. The fact is, businesses that sell more sell on Shopify. Upgrade your business and get the same checkout Mattel and Gymshark and millions of other companies use. Sign up for your $1 per month trial period at Shopify.com slash SYSK, all lowercase. Go to Shopify.com slash SYSK to upgrade your selling today. Shopify.com slash SYSK.
I'm really excited to have Factor back as a sponsor. Factor provides delicious chef-made gourmet meals right to your door. And just to be clear, this is not a box of ingredients that you have to make. These are not frozen meals. These are fresh, fully prepared meals ready to heat and eat in two minutes. And they're so good.
I first had Factor Meals delivered to me, it's been a few years now, and everyone in the house has loved them. What's really special about Factor Meals is they're dietitian approved. And the variety is impressive. There are 40 options across 8 dietary preferences on the menu each week. And you can choose from preferences like Calorie Smart, Protein Plus, or Keto. What kind of meals are they?
Well, I think you'd find these pretty tasty. Chicken Florentine with spinach and garlic chili cauliflower, Cajun spiced salmon and shrimp, garlic pork tenderloin. It's like a gourmet restaurant. And this is going to make it easy for you to try. Eat smart with Factor. Get started at factormeals.com slash something50off and use code something50off to get 50% off your first box, plus free shipping.
That's code SOMETHING50OFF at factormeals.com slash SOMETHING50OFF to get 50% off plus free shipping on your first box. And I'll put that code in the show notes to make this simple. You often hear phrases like, the human body was designed to move. Exercise is good for you. And you can often hear people talk about how much they enjoy exercising. But for a lot of other people, exercise is hard.
It's hard to start exercising and even harder to stick with it. So why is it something supposedly so necessary and natural for our health is such a challenge to do? Here to discuss that and to offer some suggestions on making exercise less of a struggle is Daniel Lieberman, professor of biological sciences and a professor of the Department of Human Evolutionary Biology at Harvard University.
He's author of a book called Exercised, Why Something We Never Evolved to Do is Healthy and Rewarding. Hi Daniel, welcome. Thank you. Pleasure to be here. So why is it, if exercise is so critical for our well-being, why is it so hard to do routinely?
Well, that's a good question. And to understand the answer to that, it's important to make a distinction between physical activity, which is moving, right? Doing anything, right? You know, sweeping the floor, buying groceries, you name it. And exercise, excuse me, which is a discretionary, voluntary physical activity for the sake of health and fitness. And we evolved to be physically active
But we didn't evolve to exercise. And the reason for that is that until recently, people had to be very physically active, but they're also energy limited. And when you're energy limited, doing unnecessary discretionary physical activity is crazy, right? Like, so for example, I ran five miles this morning, which cost me about 500 calories.
You know, when you're struggling to get enough calories, wasting 500 calories on a completely useless run in the morning is a really terrible idea. And so it's an instinct to avoid unnecessary physical activity, which is exactly what exercise is.
So this is really all part of our mechanism for survival, right?
Life is really just about, you know, food in, babies out, right? And the reason we eat food is for nutrients and calories, and calories is a unit of energy. So until recently, people struggled to get enough calories. It takes, you know, about 2,000 to 3,000 calories to run a human body for a given day. And if you're a farmer or a hunter-gatherer, getting those calories is not easy.
And you also have to pay for your children's caloric needs, their brains and all that sort of stuff. And so you're struggling to get enough calories. And so spending it on a treadmill to spend even more calories is a very odd modern thing.
And yet, there are plenty of people who do exercise and claim to love it. You ran five miles today. You didn't do it because you hate it. You did it because either you see the reward in it or you get pleasure from it or both.
Yeah, well, I mean, it's a paradox, right? We evolved to be physically active, and we have all kinds of mechanisms that reward it, right? So one of the reasons I exercise every day is that I'm addicted to it. I have a dopamine. Dopamine is the molecule of more. It's the chemical, the neurotransmitter which says, do it again, right?
And I have lots of dopamine receptors in my brain that are thirsty and hungry for more dopamine. And when I exercise, they get that dopamine hit. And if I don't exercise, they make me crabby and unpleasant. But the thing is, if you're unfit and or struggling with your weight, those dopamine receptors are going to be fewer in number and possibly even impaired in their function.
And so people who aren't already exercising a lot or being physically active
don't get the same reward so it's a it's a very strange mechanism and the reason that you might ask you know why why is that work the way it does is that in the past nobody ever was physically inactive that that just wasn't possible to you know to be active every day in order to hunt and gather or farm or whatever and so we never evolved to cope with um with a persistent physical inactivity
I remember speaking with you some years ago and I remember you telling me about other cultures where, you know, exercise is like, why would you do that? Tell that story.
I was doing research in actually northern Mexico among the Tarahumara, who call themselves the Rarámuri. They're famous for long-distance running. They have these incredible races where they sometimes run 50, 60 miles. I was being a good anthropologist and I was going around and talking to folks and asking them about their running and And about their training.
And of course, the idea of training is when you run to prepare yourself for a race. And when I was asking all these folks about training, the word didn't even exist in their language. I was working through a translator. And so I was explaining, this guy here, the translator was explaining that I ran every day.
in order to get ready for races, and the guy looked at me, and I didn't even need a translator to figure this out, and he said, why would anybody run if they didn't have to? And for me, actually, that was the beginning of the book, because I suddenly had this realization that my exercise habits are really weird.
For them, yeah. But maybe that explains why exercise is so hard, because... Because to do it artificially, to exercise for the sake of exercise, is not something humans did. We exercise to survive and to thrive, but not to exercise just to exercise. I don't imagine any other animals exercise just for the heck of it.
Well, it's not entirely true. So there's a very famous paper, one of my favorite papers, let me put it that way. There's a biologist in the Netherlands who puts mice on treadmills. And she noticed that she had mice in her backyard. And one day she thought, you know, what happens if I put a little running wheel in my backyard?
So she put a running wheel in her backyard and put some cameras on it, night cameras, went to bed. In the morning when she woke up, she looked at the camera feed and to her astonishment, wild mice in her backyard had gotten on this little running wheel and had run for a while. In fact, other animals had gotten on it too. I think a frog got on it and even a slug had gotten on the wheel.
So, you know, other animals do physical activity and why they do it
know well nobody knows right um and mice are really interesting because mice will naturally run you know several kilometers right they're a little bit unusual but uh it's certainly part of their behavior they're wired to do it but the vast majority of animals avoid unnecessary physical activity and humans are no exception except we now live in this very strange modern world where we've got elevators and shopping carts and
you know, electric can openers and you name it, right? And so basically now we don't really need to be physically active anymore, and yet our bodies require physical activity in order to turn on a whole variety of repair and maintenance mechanisms that keep us healthy. And so we've had to create in the modern industrial or post-industrial world this really weird behavior called exercise.
Which people resist like crazy. Yeah, and there's nothing wrong with them, right? It's normal. I mean, I think one of the problems with the way we think about exercise is that we make people exercise about exercise. We make them confused and anxious and feel bullied and shamed about it, right? But it's a fundamental instinct not to do physical activity unless it's rewarding or necessary. And
And so we need to be more compassionate towards our fellow human beings who are struggling to do something really weird, like get on a treadmill and run for five miles and get absolutely nowhere in a really kind of, let's face it, a very unpleasant kind of context.
Is it that exercise is so good for you or movement is so good for you or lack of movement is so bad for you? Aha.
That's exactly the point, right? Which is that we evolved to be physically active, you know, not a crazy amount, you know, two to three hours a day, basically. But that's a normal part of our environment, right? And when you remove that, then all of a sudden, all kinds of natural mechanisms which our bodies mount get turned off. And so...
And so we often say that exercise is medicine, but a really more accurate statement is that the lack of physical activity makes us more vulnerable to disease and accelerates the aging process. So exercise isn't really actually medicine. It's the lack of exercise that causes problems.
And yet when people exercise, especially when they exercise a lot, They get injured, they get hurt, they get chronic, you know, joint problems and all that. So that may be going too far.
Yeah, I mean, I think we sometimes exaggerate that stuff. I mean, look, if running was that dangerous, you know, then there could be no runners left, right? You know, I think we sometimes exaggerate injuries and that sort of thing. I mean, it is true that people exercise has trade-offs. Everything has trade-offs. There are costs and benefits to everything.
And so injury is always a potential there.
But again, remember, our ancestors weren't like running marathons, you know, they were, you know, occasionally running, they were mostly walking, they were carrying, they were doing things that don't cause injury that a lot of the stuff that we do today that causes injury is because, you know, you get weekend warriors who aren't really all that fit there, you know, they're, they're, they're, they're not, you know, prepared for the stresses that their body
then encounters and then of course they overdo it and then they get injured. But that's again a kind of weird modern way in which we exercise. And so what is your general prescription for exercise? I think we can say a few things. The first is that always some is better than none.
You know, if you just get just a little bit of physical activity every day and you just look at the outcome of that, it has enormous effects on people's health. It increases people's longevity, it decreases their vulnerability. to a wide range of diseases. And that curve continues, right?
So for example, on average, for most people, if they exercise about 20 minutes a day, which is 150 minutes a week. And it can be just like walking. It doesn't have to be running. That can decrease your overall life history, your longevity by about 30%, and reduce your vulnerability to a wide range of diseases enormously.
And then the curve continues to go down, and then eventually it kind of tails off. um and so if you do anything more than an hour a day you're not going to get any more benefit from doing an hour and 10 minutes a day or two hours a day or whatever so so basically the answer is that some is better than none more yields greater benefits but those benefits begin to tail off
And then, of course, there's variation in the kind of exercise that you do. I mean, you know, are you running? Are you walking? Are you doing strength training, you know, weights, etc.? And the answer is, you know, mix it up, right? You know, it's good to do a little bit of strength training, especially as you age.
But it's also, you know, aerobic physical activity is really important for kind of your base core, your fitness. You know, some kind of mix is always kind of important. But there's no one prescription. There never will be.
But does, you know, you go to any suburban town around the world and, you know, four or five o'clock in the afternoon, you see lots of people out walking that are clearly not athletes. They're just, you know, people out for their afternoon walk. And my guess is that most of them think that they're walking because that's good for them.
Is there some real benefit to that walk or is that, like you say, some is better than nothing, but how much good is it doing? Oh, absolutely there's a benefit to it.
There is no question about it. I mean, there are maybe a hundred studies by now, epidemiological studies, which show a dose-response curve to, for example, steps per day and various kinds of outcomes like cardiovascular disease or diabetes or just how long you live.
so for example let's take steps per day you know for most studies if you look at that curve the more steps you take the the better the outcome up until about seven or eight thousand steps a day and then the curve begins to start leveling off again these are big epidemiological studies there's a variation from person to person but sure there's no question that this physical activity has important benefits and and importantly we understand a lot of the mechanisms behind it right because when you're physically active you're
Your body produces antioxidants. Your body produces enzymes that repair proteins and repair your DNA. Your body produces all kinds of genes that work on your brain and your liver. I mean, every system of the body pretty much is affected, your immune system. People who exercise 150 minutes a week were shown in a study to be 2.5 times less likely to die of COVID.
This is before the vaccines were produced. So it affects every system of your body. And so, yeah, those folks who are out there walking are doing themselves a real benefit.
Absolutely. I remember hearing some time ago, and I don't remember where it was from, that there is a difference between exercising like on a treadmill versus exercising out in nature or something. Is there? It seems to me that exercise is exercise.
Well, for one, exercising on a treadmill is boring, in my opinion. I mean, I have a hard time. And I put people on treadmills for a living, right? I just find them...
um really hard to do but apart from that um there are if like if you just compare running on a treadmill versus running over ground um the treadmill is a little bit different because after all the ground is moving underneath you uh so it's actually pushing you in a slightly different way so a lot of people for example put the treadmill at a at a one percent incline to equal the to kind of compensate for the fact that the treadmill belt is moving
Of course, the other thing that's different about the treadmill is that every step is exactly the same. Whereas when you're in the real world, every time you land, your foot's at a slightly different angle. There are rocks and inclines and turns and all that sort of stuff. So I think treadmill running makes people much more susceptible to repetitive stress injuries.
But, you know, if you like running on a treadmill, if you like listening to a podcast on a treadmill or, you know, watching a movie or whatever, all power to you. There's nothing wrong with it. I think, you know, I think we should be, you know, whatever works for people is good.
But for whatever reason, people try to exercise and fail and give up. And, well, I think I know the reason, and I think it has to do with the failure to lose weight, that people think they're going to lose a lot of weight when they exercise. And when they don't, they say, well, see, and they quit.
Yeah, well, I mean, I think part of the problem is that we've tied so much, we just, we focus too much on weight. I think, you know, your health is what really matters. And the reason to exercise is not solely to lose weight. There are so many other benefits of just being fit. And so... even if you're not losing weight, you're still getting all kinds of wonderful benefits.
And, and look about thinking about, you know, it doesn't have to be exercise in the gym. Like how many, how many people think of dancing as exercise, but you know, go, dancing with some friends for, you know, people often will dance for hours.
We don't think of that as exercise, but it's darn good for you in all kinds of different ways, or playing a game of soccer, or playing a game of tennis, or going for a walk, or hiking with a friend or something. You know, the point is that physical activity has all kinds of benefits, and weight loss is component, but it's not the be all and end all.
And what we should really be is promoting people's health and wellbeing. And if that helps them lose weight, that's fine, but it's not the only reason to do it.
So give people some, some motivation, give people a reason to do this because, you know, it's going to be the start of the year. People are thinking, ah, I need to exercise more, but they probably won't. So how about a little motivational talk?
average everyday human beings are really extraordinary athletes and can do amazing things. And you don't need to run a marathon. You don't need to
be able to run to the top of the you know you know the empire state building or or or whatever to get the benefits of just moderate levels of physical activity and it and it affects every single system of your body it affects your immune system it affects your your brain it affects your metabolism and prevent helps prevent diabetes and heart disease you know we talk about Breast cancer.
Cancer, for example. The number one cause of death in the United States is heart disease. The number two cause of death in the United States are cancer. And both of them are majorly affected by physical activity. Women who exercise 150 minutes a day or more can have 30 to 50% lower lifetime risk of breast cancer. How many people know that? And we're not talking a huge amount of physical activity.
Physical activity is the number one way to help prevent heart disease. If you care about Alzheimer's or dementia, again, nothing comes remotely as close to physical activity as a preventative form of Alzheimer's. Now, will it guarantee that you won't get Alzheimer's, guarantee that you won't get heart disease, guarantee that you won't get cancer? No, of course not.
But nothing really comes as close. And you get all kinds of other mental health benefits. You get you know, the dopamine reward, you get serotonin reward, your brain turns on all these wonderful chemicals that affect mental health. Physical activity has been shown to be as effective as any known medication for treating depression. Now, again, will it mean that you'll never get depression?
Of course not. But all of these things together mean that, you know, there's really a lot of positives. But at the same time, I think we should also acknowledge it's also completely normal and natural to avoid it, because after all, we evolved to have to work and have to do all kinds of stuff, but we also evolved to take it easy when we could.
And so our inclinations to avoid physical activity are also deep and innate and normal and functional, and we shouldn't shame people and make them feel like somehow they're lazy for wanting to take the escalator instead of the stairs.
Well, I think that's a really important message because in all the talk of the importance of exercise and you're supposed to move and you need more activity is this idea that if you don't, there's something wrong with you, that you are lazy or there's just... there's something wrong with you, and clearly that's not the case. I've been talking to Daniel Lieberman.
He's a professor of biological sciences and a professor of the Department of Human Evolutionary Biology at Harvard. The name of his book is Exercised, Why Something We Never Evolved to Do is Healthy and Rewarding. And there's a link to that book in the show notes. Everyone has heard that eating too much salt can raise your blood pressure.
And that statement is actually based on research that was done in the 1940s that showed that people who had high blood pressure could lower it by reducing their intake of salt. As a result, it became this common advice to reduce salt in your diet to control your blood pressure.
But in the last 25 years or so, research has shown that it's not just eating a lot of salt that can elevate your blood pressure. It's also not eating enough potassium. When you eat salt, it increases the amount of sodium in your blood, which causes you to retain water, which increases your blood volume, and therefore your blood pressure.
Potassium regulates your blood pressure by stimulating your kidneys to excrete more sodium, thereby reducing blood volume and decreasing your blood pressure. So, if you don't want to cut down on salt, you can simply increase the amount of potassium you consume. Foods high in potassium include spinach, broccoli, and beans. And that is something you should know.
Hey, would you do me a favor and just take a moment, wherever you're listening to this podcast, there's a place probably where you can leave a review, or at least a rating. and just take a few words would be great, and preferably a five-star review would be great. It really does help us in ways we don't completely understand, but it really does help us.
So please, a rating and review would be appreciated. I'm Mike Carruthers. Thanks for listening today to Something You Should Know.
I'm Amy Nicholson, the film critic for the LA Times.
And I'm Paul Scheer, an actor, writer, and director. You might know me from The League, Veep, or my non-eligible for Academy Award role in Twisters.
We love movies, and we come at them from different perspectives.
Yeah, like Amy thinks that, you know, Joe Pesci was miscast in Goodfellas, and I don't.
He's too old. Let's not forget that Paul thinks that Dude 2 is overrated.
It is.
Anyway, despite this, we come together to host Unspooled, a podcast where we talk about good movies, critical hits.
Fan favorites, must-sees, and in case you missed them.
We're talking Parasite the Home Alone.
From Grease to the Dark Knight.
We've done deep dives on popcorn flicks. We've talked about why Independence Day deserves a second look.
And we've talked about horror movies, some that you've never even heard of like Ganja and Hess.
So if you love movies like we do, come along on our cinematic adventure.
Listen to Unspooled wherever you get your podcasts.
And don't forget to hit the follow button.
From the podcast that brought you to each of the last lesbian bars in the country, and back in time through the sapphic history that shaped them, comes a brand new season of cruising beyond the bars.
This is your host, Sarah Gabrielli, and I've spent the past year interviewing history-making lesbians and queer folks about all kinds of queer spaces, from bookstores to farms to line dancing and much more.
For 11 years, every night women slept illegally on the Common. We would move down to the West Indies to form a lesbian nation. Meg Christen coined the phrase women's music, but she would have liked to say it was lesbian music. And that's kind of the origins of the Combahewer Collective.
You can listen to Cruising on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes air every other Tuesday starting February 4th.