Menu
Sign In Pricing Add Podcast
Podcast Image

Today, Explained

The “Joe Rogan of the left”

Wed, 26 Mar 2025

Description

Data on who didn’t vote for the Dems is finally coming in and it’s clear that they have a problem. Can Hasan Piker be the solution? This episode was produced by Amanda Lewellyn and Travis Larchuk, edited by Amina Al-Sadi, fact-checked by Laura Bullard, engineered by Patrick Boyd and Andrea Kristinsdottir, and hosted by Sean Rameswaram. Transcript at vox.com/today-explained-podcast Support Today, Explained by becoming a Vox Member today: http://www.vox.com/members Hasan Piker at a 2018 event in Washington, DC. Photo by Kris Connor/Getty Images for The Young Turks. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Audio
Transcription

Chapter 1: Why is the 2024 election still relevant?

0.089 - 10.045 Sean Rameswaram

Today Explained here with Eric Levitz, senior correspondent at Vox.com to talk about the 2024 election. That can't be right. Eric, I thought we were done with that. I feel like I'm Pacino in three.

0

10.205 - 11.387 Hasan Piker

Just when I thought I was out.

0

14.084 - 16.206 Sean Rameswaram

Why are we talking about the 2024 election again?

0

16.546 - 29.634 Eric Levitz

The reason why we're still looking back is that it takes a while after an election to get all of the most high quality data on what exactly happened. So the full picture is starting to just come into view now.

0

30.155 - 40.181 Sean Rameswaram

And you wrote a piece about the full picture for Vox recently, and it did bonkers business on the Internet. What did it say? What struck a chord?

40.856 - 58.685 Eric Levitz

Yeah, so this was my interview with David Shore of Blue Rose Research. He's one of the biggest sort of democratic data gurus in the party. And basically, the big picture headline takeaways are... Coming up on Today Explained.

60.158 - 72.583 Unknown Speaker

3,000 action stores in Europe and we celebrate with extremely low prices. For example, Palmolive Shampoo 750ml, only 1,29. And our soft Hotel Royale cotton gloves, only 2,49. For even more extremely low prices, visit our stores or check out the app Action. Small prices, great fun.

81.035 - 100.532 Kenny Beecham

What's up, y'all? It's Kenny Beecham. We are currently watching the best playoff basketball since I can't even remember when. This is what we've been waiting for all season long. And on my show, Small Ball, I'll be breaking down the series matchups, major performances, in-game coaching decisions, and game strategy and so much more for the most exciting time of the NBA calendar.

100.932 - 107.038 Kenny Beecham

New episodes through the playoffs available on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts. Subscribe to Small Ball with Kenny Beecham so you don't miss a thing.

Chapter 2: What key trends are emerging from the 2024 election data?

Chapter 3: How did young voters shift in the 2024 election?

143.461 - 169.584 Eric Levitz

I think that what is most striking, perhaps, in his data is the movements among younger voters for the entire time that i've been covering politics there was a basic narrative where the republican party was essentially facing a ticking time bomb where they were going to have to fundamentally make more peace with social liberalism and with the welfare state

0

170.405 - 186.591 Eric Levitz

because the rising generations in the United States, millennials and Zoomers, just weren't buying what they were selling. And yeah, they can cobble together these electoral college majorities for a little while, but this is just a matter of time before we get to the progressive majority.

0

186.691 - 189.372 Unknown Speaker

Between December 2015 and March 2017, among Republicans aged 18 to 29, 23% left the party.

0

195.754 - 208.159 Unknown Speaker

This is an existential crisis for the Republican Party and we have to have a brutal discussion about it. We alienate young voters because of gay marriage. We have a policy problem. We alienate Latinos, the fastest-growing voter group in the country. There is a demographic time bomb.

0

208.564 - 228.537 Eric Levitz

What happened in 2024 completely upends that sense of demographic destiny. Voters under 30 were narrowly pro-Trump, even after going for Biden by huge margins in 2020. Every demographic group under the age of 25 is more Republican than the millennial generation was.

228.857 - 233.438 Unknown Speaker

The youth vote traditionally goes to the Democrats. Not so much in this one.

233.598 - 240.46 Sean Rameswaram

And while Harris underperformed with voters under 30, Trump gained compared to 2020. The biggest driver for Gen Z? The economy.

240.74 - 249.342 Unknown Speaker

Young people have gone from being the most progressive generation since the baby boomers to becoming potentially the most conservative.

253.323 - 257.024 Sean Rameswaram

What did we learn about why Youngs went for Trump?

Chapter 4: What explains the conservative shift among young males?

701.419 - 712.924 Andrew Morantz

There's kind of this folk theory of politics, which I think actually has some truth to it, that, like, every election has its own dominant medium. And, you know, 1960 was the TV election.

0

713.225 - 722.556 Unknown Speaker

Good evening. The television and radio stations of the United States and their affiliated stations are proud to provide facilities for 2016 was the Twitter election.

0

723.277 - 731.848 Unknown Speaker

Times listed all the people in the places and things that Donald Trump has insulted. I mean, just on Twitter. This is 282 people since the start of this campaign.

0

732.228 - 749.88 Andrew Morantz

So there was kind of this Monday morning quarterback consensus that 2024 was the livestream election or the long-form podcast election. And there was kind of this easy narrative, which was, if only there were a Rogan of the left, the Democrats would have pulled it out. And so I sort of wanted to examine how true that was.

0

750.48 - 765.31 Sean Rameswaram

And as we've covered on this show before, Trump has spent a lot of time in 2024 going... on podcasts that, you know, most people in America have never heard of. Totally. But were probably helpful to his campaign.

765.631 - 770.874 Andrew Morantz

Definitely. I mean, especially because these were pretty easy interviews, right? I mean, he wasn't really being grilled.

770.894 - 790.448 Hasan Piker

So you're way up with cocaine more than anything else you can think of. Cocaine will turn you into a damn owl, homie. I have two segments I want to do with you. The first one is use one word that comes to mind to describe that person. Okay? It's a fun game. Let's start. All right, who is the first picture? And we got the Milk Boys. One word. Great.

790.848 - 806.62 Andrew Morantz

What they did for those audiences is just expose them to a kind of humanized version of Trump. You've heard about the supervillain, you know, glowering from the Fulton County Jail or whatever. Well, here's the version of Trump that just seems like kind of a chill, approachable dude. And, you know, maybe he's not as bad as all that.

806.952 - 812.098 Hasan Piker

Alabama. And we like the Beach Boys. We always like the Beach Boys. We do like the Beach Boys. Who doesn't like the Beach Boys?

Chapter 5: How do social factors influence young voters' political views?

834.566 - 843.659 Andrew Morantz

Yeah. So, Hasan Piker is really the only major prominent leftist on Twitch, at least the only one who talks about politics all day.

0

845.509 - 851.655 Unknown Speaker

What's going on, everybody? I hope everyone's having a fantastic evening, afternoon, pre-noon, no matter where you are in the world. I'm Assam Piker, and this is Dawson on Breakfast.

0

851.675 - 870.392 Andrew Morantz

So a lot of the sort of, you know, speculation about could there be a Rogan of the left, you know, a lot of that was focused on him. He's, have to just say it outright, very, very handsome, tall, drink of water. He's, you know, that's a big part of the brand. Can I say something? I'm feeling objectified.

0

871.033 - 881.217 Andrew Morantz

oh yeah um he does sort of fitness influencer stuff he's always going to the gym and you know sending around you know thirst trap photos this guy this week has been a mess.

0

881.297 - 883.958 Unknown Speaker

You beat it. Don't act like you don't beat it.

883.978 - 886.839 Unknown Speaker

This week. Oh, I'm asking for it. What was I wearing?

887.019 - 909.347 Andrew Morantz

He, you know, plays video games. He does sort of, you know, traditionally guy coded stuff. But then he also like will like wear a pearl necklace and nail polish and, you know, hang out with his gay friends. So he's doing his own thing. But really, when he sits down to start streaming, he's basically talking about politics from a very sort of progressive socialist perspective all day long.

909.847 - 920.031 Unknown Speaker

Universal basic income in the way that I advocate for is a drastic wealth redistribution program. I think that universal basic income.

920.171 - 938.938 Andrew Morantz

He has four monitors, like a bank of monitors, like he's like a day trader or something. One is just for comments. One is just for his discord. One is his main screen. And when he's locked in, he's just locked in. Like he, you know, goes to the bathroom for 60 seconds and comes back and keeps going. He's like in a flow state for eight to 10 hours a day.

Chapter 6: What can Democrats do to reach young voters?

954.355 - 965.486 Unknown Speaker

The morality of Assad is not complex. Assad is a brutal tyrant and also, you know, a dog statesman in general. Can't speak for his and his audience.

0

966.167 - 981.576 Andrew Morantz

He had like 35,000 people live in his audience. That's like better than a lot of cable networks, especially for, you know, the coveted youth demographic. And then I come back the next day and that happens to be the day that they caught Luigi Mangione. So that was a banger of a stream.

0

Chapter 7: What is the significance of the 'Rogan of the left' concept?

982.036 - 991.062 Unknown Speaker

Normally, as you guys know, this is unlimited italiophobia in the broadcast. This is the first day where there will be no italiophobia on this broadcast. We will ban you.

0

991.782 - 1005.093 Andrew Morantz

Then I came back the next day and his guests were Lena Kahn, the FTC chair, followed by Ta-Nehisi Coates, the famous writer, followed by Stavros Halkias, the famous comedian. Back to back to back. This is like Gen Z Tonight Show kind of thing.

0

1005.414 - 1017.803 Sean Rameswaram

Right. And like Lena Kahn, Ta-Nehisi Coates, you'd expect them on like the Ezra Klein show. Mm-hmm. But maybe saying favorable things about Luigi Mangione is where Hasan Piker sort of, you know, strikes a different chord.

0

1018.284 - 1037.158 Andrew Morantz

Well, and this is the line he's constantly walking in politics of all kinds, right? He's saying Trump is a monster. You can't vote for him. But he's not then saying, here's why Kamala Harris is so great and you really should vote for her. He's basically saying she's the lesser of two evils, but she's really terrible on Gaza. She's really terrible on this other stuff.

0

1037.438 - 1044.023 Unknown Speaker

Bro, she's 60. I don't know any 60-year-old American who doesn't prefer Israel to the scary Muslims. Sometimes it's that simple.

1044.143 - 1058.374 Andrew Morantz

I mean, I was at the DNC in Chicago, and Hasan Piker was this sort of, you know, celebrated, invited guest. The DNC gave him this really prime real estate, and then he said a few too many really edgy things about Gaza. They're kicking us out.

1059.795 - 1078.12 Unknown Speaker

Unlucky. I don't know why. You think it's because you said something today that they didn't like? I did compare DNC to Israel. That might have been the final blow because we got the We got the call like shortly after I tweeted that.

1078.5 - 1099.64 Andrew Morantz

So he's constantly doing this dance, right? Trying to be a critical ally, but not too allied. Trying to be edgy on Twitch without getting kicked off Twitch. He was recently suspended for 24 hours because he talked about maybe killing Rick Scott, a senator. So it's this constant tightrope act, which, I mean, honestly makes it more exciting to watch.

1100.535 - 1105.357 Sean Rameswaram

And the audience responds to this because it strikes them as authentic.

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.