Menu
Sign In Pricing Add Podcast
Podcast Image

Sea of Lies from Uncover

S32 E1: Luck, Or Something Like It | Sea of Lies

Thu, 06 Mar 2025

Description

An unlikely discovery ten miles out to sea leaves British detectives with a dead end case. Until an accidental doorknock leads to a shocking discovery and the start of a brand new investigation.You can binge all episodes of Sea of Lies ad-free on CBC True Crime Premium on Apple Podcasts.

Audio
Transcription

Chapter 1: What unexpected event sparked the investigation?

969.201 - 990.114 Narrator

Every night at 8 p.m., the bells of All Saints Church chime the tune to Abide With Me. The hymn was written right here in Brixham in the early 19th century by a vicar whose flock was comprised almost entirely of fishermen. the chimes are thought to call home all the souls of the men lost at sea.

0

990.975 - 1017.397 Narrator

Which is to say that Brixham and the Devon Coast is a place where finding the body of an unidentified man in the ocean is not necessarily a rare occurrence. It's a holiday town, so swimmers get into trouble, leisure boats capsize, fishermen get caught in storms. And Stone's Throw Away is Barry Head, a sea cliff well-known locally as a place where people go to take their own lives.

0

1021.55 - 1055.231 Narrator

With the body now safely in the hands of the coroner and Devon police, they don't know who they have, and they don't know what they have. But lying in their mortuary was the key to unraveling a nearly perfect crime that spanned years and continents. An unimaginable web of lies was about to come undone. I'm Sam Mullins, and this is Sea of Lies from CBC's Uncover.

0

1056.351 - 1076.941 Narrator

Episode one, luck or something like it. Since Detective Ian Clenahan was both young and new in town, he'd been partnered up with a veteran of Devon Police.

0

1078.317 - 1083.581 Bill McDonald

I'm Bill McDonald, Detective Sergeant in the Dublin Cornwall Police. So I was a team leader, effectively.

1084.441 - 1098.671 Narrator

Bill is measured with his words in a way that only someone with 30 years of interrogation experience could be. We interviewed him in his purpose-built bird-watching space, where he patiently sits, confident the birds will come to him.

1099.898 - 1109.804 Bill McDonald

We felt that in the next couple of days, there would be something that would get reported, which was an explanation. Sooner or later, somebody would get reported missing.

1110.345 - 1115.108 Ian Clenahan

Because obviously that would be a case as well if your husband or brother, son, whatever, never came home.

1116.269 - 1131.354 Narrator

After two days passed without anything, MacDonald and Clenahan decided that it was time to take action. So if you were the two guys tasked with trying to learn the name of an idealist man plucked from the bottom of the ocean, Where do you even begin?

Chapter 2: Who are the key players in the fishing boat discovery?

1870.863 - 1877.968 Ian Clenahan

But it's enough to get him over to France, maybe find some accommodation so that he can then find some work to support himself.

0

1878.732 - 1899.981 Narrator

But ultimately, as to the question of what the hell happened to him, like everyone else, Davis had no idea what his friend would have been doing in Devon. Boarding a boat that would take him to France? That would make some sense. As they ended their chat on the phone, Clenahan asked if Davis could point them toward any other people who knew Ron.

0

1900.921 - 1911.927 Narrator

Davis said he'd never met Ron's family, but he knew that he had brothers. And then notably, Davis told Clenahan that Ron had once served in the military, so maybe they could find his family that way.

0

1912.668 - 1919.092 Ian Clenahan

And sure enough... He had an army record, and we were able to go to his army record and compare the dental charts.

0

1919.972 - 1926.179 Bill McDonald

They matched. And by searching his service record, it confirmed the fact that they had a record of this tattoo.

1927.241 - 1932.187 Narrator

This confirmed that they didn't just have a Ronald Platt, but this Ronald Platt.

1932.988 - 1936.332 Bill McDonald

So we're starting to get some real progress.

1936.963 - 1951.127 Narrator

Finally, with a little wind in their sails, through the army records, they were able to find a family member of Ron's in Wales. So they grabbed their coats and were out the door to meet Brian, Ronald Platt's big brother.

1951.147 - 1959.169 Bill McDonald

My brother lived in Hay-on-Wye. He welcomed me into his studio. He was a cartoonist.

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.