David McCloskey
Appearances
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
He wants the world to meet him.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Well, maybe there we should take a quick break with Edward Snowden, sort of on his rumpled bed in Hong Kong with his white t-shirt and his sunlight deprivation, talking to Laura Poitras. Let's take a quick break. When we come back, we'll see what the world does when it meets Ed Snowden.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And we are now finally at a point in the story where after Edward Snowden has taken this information, He has got about one and a half million documents on various sort of SD cards and hard drives. He is in Hong Kong now, sort of ensconced in a disgusting hotel room filled with cartons of takeaway food.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And in everyday life, Gordon, well, they usually are, but not spies, data brokers, quietly collecting your personal information, building detailed profiles, and then selling them on without a warrant and without any warning.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And once it's out there, it spreads to scammers, identity thieves, really anyone with a Wi-Fi signal and bad intentions. That's why we use Incogni.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Think of it as your own digital counterintelligence service. So head to incogni.com slash rest is classified for 60% off an annual plan. That's incogni.com slash rest is classified. This episode is sponsored by NordVPN, which, Gordon, frankly, is essential if you'd rather not have your online life monitored like some Cold War embassy. Who wants that?
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
It's like having your own digital dead drop. Secure, untraceable, nobody quietly rifling through your browsing history or collecting your personal information. And so threat protection works even when the VPN's off. So even if you forget to switch it on, it's still covering your back. It also encrypts your data on public Wi-Fi. Think cafes, airports, hotels.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
So you're not handing your information over to whoever's lurking on the same network.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Plus, there's a 30-day money-back guarantee. No risk, no trace, no loose ends. The link is in the episode description.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Well, welcome back. We are here continuing Gordon Carrera's quest to make me read every absolute jackalope statement that Edward Snowden has ever made. And it is Sunday, the 9th of June, 2013. Ed Snowden is allowing the world, in his own words, to meet him. Finally, in a video that Laura Poitras, the filmmaker, is filming of Ed Snowden in his hotel room in Hong Kong.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And Snowden makes, let me read again. Gordon, thank you for this wonderful death march.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Okay, this is Ed Snowden, June 9th, 2013, from Hong Kong. I could be rendered by the CIA. I could have people come after me, or any of the third-party partners. They work closely with a number of other nations. Or they could pay off the triads. Any of their agents or assets. We've got a CIA station just up the road, the consulate here in Hong Kong.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
He is now in a room with journalist Glenn Greenwald, Ewan McCaskill from The Guardian, and Laura Poitras, a filmmaker. And now June 5th, 2013, this first article drops and it's a massive one.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And I'm sure they are going to be very busy for the next week. And that is a fear I will live with for the rest of my life, however long that happens to be. You can't come forward against the world's most powerful intelligence agencies. and be completely free from risk. Because they are such powerful adversaries, no one can meaningfully oppose them.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
If they want to get you, they will get you in time. But at the same time, you have to make the determination about what is important to you. Thank you for reading that so beautifully. Yes, and for those not watching on video, I have a large bottle of Colgate mouthwash I've been using to rinse my mouth out after reading all of this. So look, that is just one part of the video.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
It sounds like something that a sort of enterprising spy thriller writer might include in one of their insane spy thrillers. Yeah, I was going to say, perfect dialogue. Perfect dialogue for you. Great dialogue, yeah.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
But I think it does tell you something about his worldview, doesn't it? I realize that there will be a batch of listeners who would assume that this is what the former CIA guy is going to say. But what Snowden is alleging here is ridiculous, that the CIA would attempt to render him from China. I mean, the US will later on request that the Chinese government send him back home.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
But the idea here is somehow that there are going to be a group of CIA paid triads that break into his hotel room and put a bag over his head and put him on a Gulfstream to fly back to Washington. I mean, it's actually... And I think it shows you how much of a video game he has turned this into.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Who's just gone public. Yeah. That's right. But yes, you're right. But again, it's this idea that he's filtering.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
It does raise the question of what he thought would happen, I think. Because in my view is that he probably thought once these articles came out- that he would be able to go someplace like, I think he even mentioned this as a possibility, like Iceland. Even at this point, I don't think that in his mind, China or Russia are the preferred sort of destinations. Yeah, I think that's true.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
I think he believed, again, in this kind of image of him as, hey, I'm the hero in this story, and it's self-evident that what I'm doing is right. I think he believed that someplace more
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Now, is that interview the first time that one of his leaks was connected to the US just straight up spying on a foreign adversary. Because that is another piece of this that is obviously not sat well with most Americans, I think, since is that he's revealing here in this interview in China, which by the way, I think
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
in the context of all of these massive articles coming out in The Guardian the week prior, was sort of ignored, is that he's actually revealing something about just the US spying on a foreign adversary. This had nothing to do with domestic collection. Mass surveillance.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
After all those failed attempts by the triads, the CIA hired triads to get into his hotel room. Finally had to play it straight. The base chief in Hong Kong was just furious at the end of the week.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
The order, a copy of which has been obtained by The Guardian, requires Verizon on a quote, ongoing daily basis to give the NSA information on all telephone calls in its systems, both within the U.S. and between the U.S. and other countries. The document shows for the first time that under the Obama administration, the communications records of millions of U.S.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
I guess as he goes, he's got to balance the threat of maybe immediate extradition, right? If you go to some place like Iceland and it goes south, you just maybe get sent home much more quickly, straight away. Whereas Hong Kong, you've got a bit more... There's maybe a little bit more political leeway. And so maybe he's got to balance this kind of intermediate kind of airlock, right? Where he's...
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
He's potentially going to use the leaks and how that sort of gets filtered publicly to build enough credibility to get a place that he considers sort of open to internet freedom or privacy to then accept him. And obviously, it doesn't pan out that way at all.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Enter WikiLeaks.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
But I suppose they've got to create an itinerary that hopscotches through territories where he will not be extradited, right?
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
You always say that route. That is my preferred way to go. The whistleblower express. Yeah, the whistleblower express. I mean, my WikiLeaks minder next to me. You know, you do have to wonder now, With all that has come out, particularly around sort of WikiLeaks, Russia connections. Yeah. If at some point Assange may have mentioned Snowden to some of his Russian contacts. along this path.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
It's just a breezy speculation from a former CIA guy.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
So then, as we have discussed... is an interesting combination as a potential intelligence target of egomania bravery and lack of guile. Naivety. Naivety. You could say innocence. And I think in this case, I could certainly buy that Snowden did not understand the implications of traveling through Moscow. But Sarah Harrison? We don't know who suggested it. I mean, yeah.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
It's very interesting, though. It is. It is.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
The Chinese are keen to get rid of the political hot potato. Yeah. And the Russians, maybe someone inside, Assange had mentioned it to somebody, and someone at the FSB says- Let's let this guy come.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
The Aeroflot people in Hong Kong. Yeah.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
I mean, of all of the shocking revelations in our series here, the idea of an outbound flight from Moscow being dry might be among the most interesting that we've encountered. I think that's bizarre. Also, the newspapers are approving these expense reports. It's the big story. These outbound flights are just roping on an economy flight from Moscow to Venezuela.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And of course, members of the Declassified Club are able to hear that straight away. And also listeners following the news, Gordon, will see that the Bulgarian spy ring we did a few episodes on a few weeks ago, well, they've been sentenced. And this Friday, we have an absolute treat. For club members, we have recorded an interview with the head of Scotland Yard's Counterterrorism Division.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Now, he was in charge of that case. He has an absolute insider's view on the minions, on those Bulgarians. It's the perfect complement to those episodes. And if you want to hear that, just go ahead and join the Declassified Club at therestisclassified.com. and take advantage of our launch discount. That's right.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Here you are. It's 2025 and we're talking Scotland Yard and minions. I believe he did talk about minions and refer to them as minions once or twice, maybe reluctantly.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Now, I will interject here.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
the U.S. intelligence community. In defense of James Clapper, I must interject just a couple other points of context that you have left out of this, Gordon, which is this was an open hearing. Now, for those who have seen the video, It would have been hard, I think, to picture James Clapper looking more uncomfortable when he answered that question.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
He's constantly sort of scratching his bald head, probably thinking, why in the hell is this guy asking me this question? I think... that the real mistake here that Clapper made was not answering the question in that way, because how could he have answered that responsibly in an open hearing? Yeah. It probably was not correcting the record afterward.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Also, I'll note this Clapper testimony in the sort of Edward Snowden, you know, revisionist history of all of this. In the Snowden history, the Clapper testimony is this sort of turning point for him, right? Yeah. That brings us back to my Snowden deadly sins, right?
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And if you recall from earlier episodes of the list, sin number two, impure motive, Snowden's bulk download started months prior to the Clapper testimony. But I agree with you that, and I think this is something that will be a thread connecting the rest of the episodes in our wonderful series on Snowden is, there is a
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
tremendous gap between the understanding of this program, I think, inside the upper reaches of Congress and the intelligence community in the White House, and what the American people think is happening. That's where this article is such a bombshell, because Americans prior to this, ordinary people, did not have an understanding that any of this was authorized. Exactly.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
citizens are being collected indiscriminately and in bulk, regardless of whether they are suspected of any wrongdoing. The disclosure is likely to reignite longstanding debates in the U.S. over the proper extent of the government's domestic spying powers. Well, welcome to The Rest Is Classified. I'm David McCloskey. And I'm Gordon Carrera.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Well, and Prism is the codename for this program. And I think it is important, very important to note that this is targeting individuals the communications of foreign nationals. The intent behind this is for the United States government, for NSA to be able to query this database, essentially, and to be able to look at email, et cetera, of foreign nationals who are outside the United States. But
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
As that's being collected, you're, of course, collecting the information of Americans at the same time, right? Who are sort of swept up in these searches. But you're not- They're not the target of it. They're not the target of it, right? It's sort of- almost being collected incidentally by the NSA.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
It's got these logos. I would argue very easy to draw on. whatever conclusion you like from that slide deck.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And that, for those who have been listening to our series on Edward Snowden, is the first time, thank you, Gordon, that I have not been forced to read an opening quote from Edward Snowden's memoir, Permanent Record. That is instead... a quote from an absolute bombshell of a new story dropped by The Guardian on June 5th, 2013.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And important to note, it was legal. The tech companies knew this was happening. So a lot of the outrage that came afterward from Silicon Valley was primarily that it was leaked, not that it was happening.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And the legal basis for this was something called Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which FISA, that act had been passed in the 70s, been updated, amended over time. The authorities that NSA was operating under, FBI was operating under, were, I believe, part of the 07-08 FISA Act.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And that Section 702 is what really compelled, in many ways, these tech companies to provide that information to the federal government.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
The National Security Agency is currently collecting the telephone records of millions of U.S. customers of Verizon, one of America's largest telecoms providers, under a top secret court order issued in April.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Well, and I think it is important to note here, again, in Deadly Sin number four, Snowden, indiscriminate, leaking.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
There is a massive question when you raise this issue of Snowden even understanding what in the world was on these slides. So there's an annual training inside NSA on Section 702 and FISA and how those queries could happen and the sort of legality and framework for understanding really PRISM. And Snowden had failed his annual training on Section 702, right?
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And I will note, though, Gordon, in my effort to take extreme offense at all opening quotes, that this story was broken by a British newspaper, which is also offensive to me. But also an American journalist.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
So, it is, again, I think an important fact to bring to bear in this is that he was outraged by this program, much in the way, you know, out in Hawaii, he'd been outraged by acts where he thought the government was sort of intervening as censor or whatever, but had not read the bills. I think, again, in this case, he is, I mean, and there's no doubt that this is an important
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
civil liberties topic, but at the same time, Edward Snowden does not actually understand, I think, what the NSA is doing as demonstrated by his inability to even pass the annual training on this.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
Too many people.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
And they probably do know, as we discussed last time, that someone's missing. He's missing.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
That's right. That's right. Well, and for those tuning in here, we are on our fourth episode of our journey into the darkness of Edward Snowden's leaks.
The Rest Is Classified
46. The Leak That Changed The World: Snowden On The Run (Ep 4)
But luckily, he's a massive narcissist with a... Massive ego, right? He is a Tekken warrior for his clan, Gordon. But it's so interesting. Single combat against the US government. He can't hide in the shadows.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And in everyday life, Gordon, well, they usually are. But not spies. Data brokers. Quietly collecting your personal information, building detailed profiles, and then selling them on without a warrant and without any warning.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And once it's out there, it spreads to scammers, identity thieves, really anyone with a Wi-Fi signal and bad intentions.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Think of it as your own digital counterintelligence service. So head to incogni.com slash rest is classified for 60% off an annual plan. That's incogni.com slash rest is classified. This episode is sponsored by NordVPN, which, Gordon, frankly, is essential if you'd rather not have your online life monitored like some Cold War embassy.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Also in this period, I will note that Dell had tried to move him in about September of 2010 to a position where he would support IT systems at CIA. But... But, and for those watching, this is a Scattered Castles reference, so mark it down. Because of his DROG mark, his sort of black flag mark, in Scattered Castles, the system that manages clearances, Dell couldn't put him in that position.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
It's like having your own digital dead drop. Secure, untraceable, nobody quietly rifling through your browsing history or collecting your personal information.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
It also encrypts your data on public Wi-Fi. Think cafes, airports, hotels. So you're not handing your information over to whoever's lurking on the same network.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Plus, there's a 30-day money-back guarantee. No risk, no trace, no loose ends. The link is in the episode description.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
All right, well, welcome back. We are with Edward Snowden. He is bunkered under a pineapple field in Hawaii with headphones on, probably looking quite vampiric after a night of playing video games and arriving late to work. Edward Snowden has now moved in his sort of ongoing odyssey through the United States secret state.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
He has moved and he is now an analyst working for another contractor, right? Booz Allen Hamilton.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Still in Hawaii. Still working under contract for NSA, but at this other contractor, Booz Allen. And it is 2012. He has started... And despite his sort of sunlight deprived looks, Edward Snowden has a tremendous amount of access inside this world and is starting to really harvest it. Yeah.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Well, I suppose, you know, that wonderful quote you made me read at the beginning of this episode, Gordon, about Stoughton having access to every communication on planet Earth. It's total garbage, right? I mean, it's not true, but I think his access to like a sort of a search like X-Keyscore, a tool like that,
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
gave him, you know, I think in his own kind of serial fabricator mind, the willingness to say that because he does have access. It's true, right? He has access to a tremendous amount of information.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
They had to find another spot for him that didn't require the same level of security clearance. And so he ends up kind of back in another role and then eventually in Hawaii. Yeah.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Well, I've seen the PowerPoint documents that have leaked. The complexity makes me wonder if I would be able to operate XP score because I think I would stare befuddled at the screen for a while without being able to use it. And Snowden even, I mean, and we'll, I'm sure, come to this a little bit later. He did claim... to have wiretapped a bunch of Congress people and Supreme Court judges.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
I think most maybe outsiders who are looking at intelligence community buildings or sites through the lens of Hollywood would probably be surprised to know that there are basically no
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
checks yeah once you're in the system right once you're kind of inside you're cleared yeah obviously if you were carrying a garbage bag of documents out yeah someone might stop him but if you're carrying an sd card or if you have you know 30 pages of documents or something in a briefcase or a bag, no one's checking this stuff. You could just walk out.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And it actually, I mean, I remember every day leaving CIA, kind of going through this process, and it was a little stressful actually, of trying to check all of my bags and stuff to make sure that I wasn't carrying anything out on accident that was highly classified. And that kind of thing happened all the time. I mean, I had
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
friends who, and analysts actually tend to sweat this more than the case officers, because the case officers are out there in the world, you know, recruiting people and kind of dealing with classified stuff outside of a SCIF, you know, a secure department and information facility or vaults. I had a friend who would walk out and he walked out one time with a document he shouldn't have.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
He was about to have a heart attack. The point is, it's easy.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Well, and you've just teed up my fourth deadly sin of Edward Snowden, Gordon, which is completely indiscriminate.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Leaking, right? So 1.5 million documents are what he takes. The vast majority, of course, unrelated documents any of the domestic kind of surveillance programs that so angered him. How high, Gordon, do you think those documents would reach into the sky if they were stacked? I don't know, but you're going to tell me. I am going to tell you. To the moon. I'm going to tell you in kilometers even.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
So the measure that you will understand, five kilometers high.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
If you stack those up. Okay. He's a system administrator. So he's got access to massive databases kind of read write delete access right so you can see all this stuff so the scraping tools that he uses to do these downloads are more or less completely indiscriminate now he does do some specific searches right but he's scraping through these databases He has no idea what's even on these.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And there's an interesting kind of techie reason for some of this, which is that when senior NSA officials would come from around the world, come from Fort Meade and would log on to computers out at Hawaii, essentially their hard drive, what was on their system, really their user profile rather, in D.C. at Fort Meade would replicate that. out in Hawaii.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And so a lot of the flashier, sexier PowerPoints that ended up getting leaked initially are because senior NSA policy people had come out, not to meet with Snowden, but for other meetings in Hawaii.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And their files are downloaded there and he pulls them. Okay. Unknowingly, in many cases, off of these databases.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
That's good. I'm going to steal that for a novel.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And I do agree with that. And I'm grateful that Edward Snowden did not go the WikiLeaks route. It also bears mentioning that If he had gone the WikiLeaks route and just pushed them out, he would have given Assange and his organization, or something like it, the credit. I think at his core, Edward Snowden, good, bad, and ugly, is a narcissist.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
It would have been almost unthinkable for him to just push this stuff out there and not be the face of it. It's actually more strategic for someone who wants to be the face of this thing and to kind of ride this. to have journalists or somebody else writing stories that you can sort of catapult yourself on.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
He has a five kilometer high stack, three miles for our American listeners of documents, 1.5 million documents. And he's going to try to give them to journalists. And so I guess, I mean, the question here is, well, who is he going to reach out to? Which journalist is he going to try? And who's really going to help him tell this story?
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
I think as he sees it, this fantastic story, this lewd story about the surveillance state, NSA spying on Americans, and it's all going to lead into an absolutely insane encounter and really a chase, I think, in a most unusual place.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And we may also finally give me an opportunity, Gordon, to watch War Games, right? And discuss it with you. Thus completing my delayed entry into American manhood. So thank you for listening and we will see you next time. See you next time.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Well, and he's also remembered in this period for not being able to show up to work on time, which I'll just mention in my fact.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Right. And apparently because he's playing video games so late at night, you know, and again, it's this kind of thread of this guy is smart, actually likable in many respects. He's introverted, but, you know, he's got a long term girlfriend. He's got relationships with people, but he's not really able to kind of function properly. in a normal work environment.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
There is another feature here, which is colleagues from... the sort of pineapple bunker, remember that Snowden was sort of very... He would come out and say that, okay, well, things like the Stop Online Piracy Act and the Protect Intellectual Property Act, these are going to lead to online censorship, which is a theme of his. He's very concerned about that. Free internet is what he wants.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
But then he'll admit to having read neither bill and not understanding really what's in them. So I do think you also see... these glimmers in this period, even earlier, of somebody who is extremely certain about his beliefs, does have... Ideological beliefs. Ideological beliefs.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And despite the fact that I think that line, Gordon, that I just read, that you just made me read, which is actually the better way to say it, is completely fabricated. Deadly sin number one from Edward Snowden. We're going to talk a little bit today about really Snowden's journey to getting to a point where he is sitting on top of a trove of massive secrets.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
He's not just a mercenary, but he jumps to conclusions very quickly, gets to very certain conclusions very quickly about those beliefs. Yeah, I think that's right.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Well, no, I don't buy it. There's a very kind of critical period in the middle of 2012 that's kind of essential to this. But up until that point, I mean, it is probably worth us talking a little bit about that kind of access he had. Because he does end up in a unique position to take a massive trove of documents.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And he's kind of pulling together it is, you know, because again, in Hawaii, I mean, I think he'll say he had like 30 minutes of work to do a day of actual work. So he starts kind of pulling together what is this program called Heartbeat, where he's essentially trying to create a centralized repository for a lot of the documents he's going to end up stealing.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Well, if you enter Edward Snowden on Google, his tagline will say NSA whistleblower. Yeah. And that's how he pops up. But I think this is... Deadly sin number two.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
So this is impure motives.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
This is critical to understand because lost in all of the memoirs, a lot of the very positive reception that Snowden's leaks received is a very critical piece of the timeline, which is you get to June of 2012. Okay. He's in Hawaii and Snowden has a massive fight with his supervisors over what else? A software patch that gets deployed. It fails. Right.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And there is a fight on his team between supervisors over why this happened. And. Essentially what Snowden does, which is similar to what he did in his very kind of first months at CIA, is in this back and forth fight, he sends a note like three or four levels above the chain to a senior NSA employee at Fort Meade. And keep in mind, Snowden is a contractor working for Dell.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
So rightly or wrongly, he's not a blue badge NSA employee working at the fork. So he's elevated this issue massively. This obviously doesn't go well for him. There's a note that comes back. He gets a quick rebuke from Washington. His behavior is, quote, totally unacceptable. Unacceptable in all caps. And so you can only imagine what's going on in the cubicle form out under that pineapple field.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And it is two weeks after this. June, 2012 incident that he starts these bulk downloads. So I think the recipe of sort of the sauce here of Snowden's decision, I think really matters a lot. And my view is that it's kind of three things, right? Number one, you have a guy who has this incredible certainty in his own beliefs, his own kind of worldview that feels like he's been put down by the system.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
wronged by the system that he should be way ahead of where he is. He should probably have his boss's job or his boss's boss's job. And so I think you do at the base level have this kind of
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
revengers tale that has the ideology this kind of you know free internet privacy thing layered on top but in in my view the facts the chronology of sort of when he starts down this journey show it to be very much motivated by revenge
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
I had practically unlimited access to the communications of nearly every man, woman, and child on earth who ever dialed a phone or touched a computer. All right. Well, that was Edward Snowden, also from his memoir, Permanent Record. And we're back with episode two of the Edward Snowden journey.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Well, I think that's my third deadly sin, Gordon, is that he doesn't avail himself of these channels. And I agree with you that you could look at Thomas Drake, you could look at these case studies of NSA folks who had tried and it had not gone well for them. But what I find... Interesting is that Snowden is perfectly willing throughout his career to go to the IG. The Inspector General.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
To go to superiors with all manner of grievances, complaints, issues that have... been detrimental to his career. And so, number one, I think given the nature of the information that he's going to leak, there are protections for this. There's a 1998 Whistleblower Protection Act that would have covered contractors. There are DOD regs that cover this.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
He could have gone to any number of House Intel or Senate Intel Committee staffs with specific documents and brought them to their attention, right? But he doesn't. For someone who has shown himself willing to go to those authorities in the past, I think there's a level of irresponsibility, right, with this material. This is material that is funded by the U.S. taxpayer.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
So to not go through some of those channels, I just think, man, that's an irresponsible decision.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
Well, and I'll just again, add to my, Deadly sin number one on Edward Snowden's track record of fabrication was one of the documents that he's going to take or one set of documents he's going to take in this 2012 period, mid 2012. He's going to steal the test and the answer key for a job inside a group at NSA called TAO, Tailored Access Operations, which is essentially in that era.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
is the NSA's elite hackers, the guys and girls who go out and try to access, really hard to access networks of our foreign adversaries. And Snowden applies for this job, but he's already, I mean, this is where I think you do get this kind of jumbled set of motives
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
for why he's taking all these documents because I guess he could have chanced upon this and then thought, well, I've got the test, I might as well apply. But he also does have some very mercenary potential motives for some of these document thefts. But he takes this test and... of course, passes it with flying colors, right? Because he's got all the answers.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And then he gets offered, and again, I think this is a great insight into his personality, because he gets offered a job working inside TAO, which by the way is a premier, inside NSA is a premier job to have. Gets offered a GS-12, government scale 12 role inside TAO and turns it down Because he felt he should have been offered a GS-15 salary.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
And this, again, it's absolutely fascinating because you just... Let's get into some of these facts around how this guy behaved and who he is. He's 29 at that point. And I mean, it's a little bit different kind of depending on the agency. But... It would probably have taken a really competent – no, he joins when he's 23. He gets into the secret world.
The Rest Is Classified
44. The Leak That Changed The World: Stealing State Secrets (Ep 2)
It would have taken 14, 15 years, something like that, for a competent person to rise to the level of GS-15. Yeah. He's been in for six and he's already thinking, well, I should have my 15. Anyway, he turns down the TA role and stays in Hawaii. But there's some really interesting aspects to this guy's character that I think get left out of the geography.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And it's insane, right? The journalists who are looking at this are like, look, this guy, it makes him look like, I would say, a privacy jihadist. Yeah. I'm not sure I'd use the jihadist term.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
I believe that he's told them who he is. Yeah. Right. These journalists, because he up until this point, he'd been using. Yeah.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Yeah. And this time he reveals that he's Ed Snowden. He reveals his social security number. He reveals. I love this. His CIA funny name was Dave M. Churchyard. Yeah. Which is a relatively bizarre one. But those funny names, which are ridiculous, there was always a rumor.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
They're generated by a computer, but there was always a rumor that the sort of, I guess, upstream, like the thing that was fed into that computer originally was a British phone book from the night, like a London phone book from the 1950s that would sort of go and pull pieces of names to put them together. Like I had a ridiculous one. I actually can't share it.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
But it's always a first name. Yes. It's always a first name, middle initial. It doesn't necessarily mean anything, but we'd always come up with what it meant internally. And then a weird last name. And there were actually a few people I knew who the program... It just gets generated, right? When you join.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
The program generated one for them that was so inappropriate that they actually had to go through a formal process to try to get it changed because it had already been issued. But Dave M. Churchyard...
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
You might have access to the CIA database. This is another example when he says, hey, I'm Ed Snowden, Dave M. Churchyard. Where again, we have deadly sin number one, Edward Snowden, serial fabricator, where when he's describing his... He says to Poitras and Greenwald, he's a senior advisor at NSA under corporate cover. Not true. He's a contractor. He's working for Dell.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
He says he's a lecturer at the Defense Intelligence Agency. He had stepped in and given a few lectures once when someone got sick.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
You know what I mean? It's all he needs to do is provide them one document on Prism and they're hooked. And yet he's got this whole kind of persona that he's built up in his own mind, right, of how important he is. and it's just even seeping through in what he leaks to the journalists.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
They were flummoxed at the addition of a credible journalist. Well, yeah. To the soup that Edward Snowden was...
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
So there we are. Are we going to skip Pat? You're not going to let me read any lines from his manifesto, Gordon? Go on then. I know you love reading. You're making me read from his polished memoir. I can't read from the deranged lines from the manifesto. Do it, David. Okay. There's a lot here. Yeah, just pick your favorites. I'll pick a couple. Here's a great one.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
As I advanced and learned the dangerous truth behind the U.S. policies that seek to develop secret, irresistible powers and concentrate them in the hands of an unaccountable few, Human weakness haunted me as I worked in secret to resist them. Selfish fear questioned if the stone thrown by a single man could justify the loss of everything he loves.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And Edward Sona is right back there playing Tekken as a 13 year old. Who cares what your clan thinks? You're out there in single combat with your own ideas about how to defend them.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And in everyday life, Gordon, well, they usually are, but not spies, data brokers, quietly collecting your personal information, building detailed profiles, and then selling them on without a warrant and without any warning.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And once it's out there, it spreads to scammers, identity thieves, really anyone with a Wi-Fi signal and bad intentions.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Think of it as your own digital counterintelligence service. So head to incogni.com slash rest is classified for 60% off an annual plan. That's incogni.com slash rest is classified. This episode is sponsored by NordVPN, which, Gordon, frankly, is essential if you'd rather not have your online life monitored like some Cold War embassy. Who wants that?
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
It's like having your own digital dead drop. Secure, untraceable, nobody quietly rifling through your browsing history or collecting your personal information. And so threat protection works even when the VPN's off. So even if you forget to switch it on, it's still covering your back. It also encrypts your data on public Wi-Fi. Think cafes, airports, hotels.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
So you're not handing your information over to whoever's lurking on the same network.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Plus, there's a 30-day money-back guarantee. No risk, no trace, no loose ends. The link is in the episode description.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Well, welcome back. We are with Edward Snowden. He is stuck in a horribly dank hotel room in Hong Kong. And now journalists are on the way, finally, to meet with him to hear his story.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
It's not actual alligator skin.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
It feels like a really great way to stand out in the middle of a hotel. Yeah. to be standing there holding a Rubik's Cube. If you're trying to fly under the radar, a Rubik's Cube working on it like some kind of lunatic in the middle of a hotel, perhaps sprawled across an alligator skin looking leather couch is not the most sort of clandestine way to make contact.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
He's probably watching them from somewhere else.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
After having seen the documentary, I'm not sure I would describe him as chic nerd glasses.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Greenwald also says that Snowden looked like he had only recently started shaving. Yeah. Perhaps new at the practice.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
I wonder why they thought he was going to be so much older.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
He's back in his parents' basement playing Tekken.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
He should have sprung for the suite.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
You wrote here, Gordon, in this...
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
in our notes he tried using spy tricks involving water and soy sauce patterns on a piece of paper to see if anyone came in while he was out yeah i didn't understand that in my notes i wrote wtf is this yeah what is that i don't know it's something to do with like if the water falls on the soy sauce then it you get a pattern and you can i don't know i didn't understand an elaborate soy sauce drip machine and set up yeah triggered by the door
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Well, there's a great segment in Citizen Four, the documentary, where it's when Ewan has showed up. And, you know, Ewan sits down and he's kind of got, unlike Greenwald, you kind of get the sense that, and I think, you know, Ewan, I don't know if this is his style, but he's not really trying to establish a lot of rapport right away with Snowden. He's trying to establish some facts.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And so he says, you know, tell me, I think it's more like, who are you? And Snowden starts to give his life story and job description. And Ewan's like, no, what's your name? Yeah. It stalled at the beginning. And he has him spell the name out. One other thing that is interesting, because you can see all of this on Citizen Four. Snowden, why did he wear that white t-shirt the whole time?
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
He's being filmed. It was a terrible wardrobe decision. Yeah.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Well, I don't know.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
It's interesting because obviously that is a huge deal for Ewan, for Glenn, for Laura Poitras. But the room, it's pretty tense in that room. You can feel it even in the documentary. I mean, it's cramped. It's confined, of course. But-
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
I think it's an interesting question from a journalistic perspective, but you could make the same parallel if, and by the way, I'm not saying he's being run by a foreign intelligence service, but just more generally, a comparison between this encounter and a CIA case officer convincing someone to spy for them.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Because you have someone who's really about to jump off a cliff.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And he has put really his life and his reputation snowed in. in the hands of these journalists.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
again, to take kind of the lens of, to some degree, the journalist, to some degree, he's a volunteer here. To some degree, the journalists are recruiting him. There's a little bit of a push and pull.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
I think Snowden's psychological combination here is really perfect from the standpoint of journalists trying to break stories or be from the standpoint of a police officer recruiting an asset because he has, you said innocence or naivete, and I think that's right. I mean, there's a complete lack of guile that he has He's smart, but he sort of lacks that kind of, I don't know, meanness to him.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
He's kind of an innocent, naive kid, I guess you'd say, in some ways, who is not, importantly, not a coward, right? That's tough to recruit because if he's a coward, he doesn't want his name out there. But what he has instead is a massive ego.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And a nice little sign of Edward Snowden's subterranean narcissism.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And so you combine those things, that lack of guile with a massive ego, and you have someone who's willing to take a massive step, put his name out there as the source of all this stuff.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Because they're literally writing stories like in the room.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
You've got to actually contact people in the NSA or the intelligence community to start, I mean, at least saying we have something and we're going to run it.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Also, Snowden, and you can even see this in the documentary, is he's dealing with personal stuff back home too, right? Because as this story is kind of coming to a head, his absence has been missed now in Hawaii, right? And police have been out to see his girlfriend in Hawaii. And there's kind of a sense, and you kind of see him troubled by this in the documentary, right?
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
That even though he's told his girlfriend, Lindsay Mills, absolutely nothing about what he's done or even where he is, that as I read in his sort of deranged manifesto, this idea that he was going to incur a massive personal cost for doing this. I mean, that is true, right? And that net is starting to close on him.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
So at CIA – and I imagine it's true at NSA too – If you don't show up, you could just be sick or something bad written. If you don't show up, they'll call you, contact you. And if you don't answer, they will send people. to your house, your apartment to check on you. So it could be the case here that he had said, hey, I need a week. Yeah, and he's been off for longer.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And he's been off for a little bit longer. And then they call. He doesn't respond. Then someone goes out to the house. And so I think it's very possible that it's not like they were spying on him, but that he was gone longer than they had thought. And if you have an employee with a top secret security clearance who has essentially gone AWOL, You check it.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Well, and it really is an absolute banger of a story that's going to turn the entire United States and its intelligence community completely upside down. So maybe... There we'll leave poor Edward Snowden in his decrepit, smelly hotel room in Hong Kong. And when we return, we'll see what in the world that earth-shaking story had to say.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And rumor is that first prize draw, Gordon, is going to be for lucky winners to receive a copy of your latest book, The Spy in the Archive, signed by you. Isn't that right?
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
I signed it with my call letter nickname, Echo. Then I went to the airport and bought a ticket in cash for the next flight to Tokyo. In Tokyo, I bought another ticket in cash, and on May 20th arrived in Hong Kong, the city where the world first met me. Okay. Welcome to The Rest Is Classified. I'm David McCloskey. And I'm Gordon Carrera.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Well, I mean, honestly, in the documentary about Snowden, Citizen Four, there is a scene where Greenwald and Snowden are sitting together. And Greenwald, I'm actually kind of shocked it was in the documentary because it's just Greenwald for about 60 seconds struggling with technology on his laptop. So he is an ideal character. mouthpiece for Snowden because he is at heart a civil liberties lawyer.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
He's an advocate. He is going to be less skeptical of Snowden than many other journalists, right? But he doesn't know how to use PGP.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Is that a normal thing, Gordon, is to have someone who could be legit or could be a total whack job encrypting? Reaching out with some, you know, sort of tantalizing hint that they've got a great story for you. I mean, that must happen some frequency.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And she's based in Berlin.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And that, unfortunately, dear listeners, was yet another reading from Edward Snowden's memoir, Permanent Record. And we are now, for those who have been listening to this wonderful series about... Edward Snowden.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Critically, both of these journalists are outside of the US.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
So he starts contacting Greenwald in December of 2012. We're now three or so months later. He's not provided any documents, right? He kind of hasn't shown his bona fides.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
It does make me think a little bit of... the series we did earlier in the year on Adolf Tolkachev, where he reaches out to the CIA four, five, six times and essentially gets the cold shoulder.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
She's actually received a stolen document from the National Security Agency at this point.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
We are now at a really a critical kind of turning point in this story because Edward Snowden is taking the plunge and he is going to finally reach out to journalists to get his information out to the world. And I think it's probably worth a little bit of How did we get here? Yep. Snowden, up to this point, he's been a CIA officer, technical officer. He's been a contractor for the NSA.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
If you put yourself, Gordon, in Greenwald or Poitras' shoes. What do you do? I'm fascinated with this as someone who's inside the CIA and knows that if someone had sent me a top secret document, I would have to report it immediately to security and kind of There's a whole procedure. But as a journalist, I mean, what's the play here, right?
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
I mean, so you've got a document that's really interesting. And then you have a source who says, I want you to go meet me in Hong Kong. There's probably no playbook here.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
I took an emergency medical leave of absence from work, citing epilepsy, and packed scant luggage and four laptops, secure communications, normal communications at Decoy, and an air gap, a computer that had never gone and would never go online. I left my smartphone on the kitchen counter alongside a notepad, on which I scribbled in pen, got called away for work, I love you.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And I think, right, that Hong Kong is suspicious solely because it's part of China, right? So it immediately casts kind of this shadow over the leaks because it, at first blush, could make it look like he's under the control of or sort of being influenced by maybe the Chinese intelligence services.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
I think it also does show a bit of Snowden's naivete in the signal that this move would send to these journalists, right? Because it does immediately – and this is one of the things that's going to color a lot of the stories – The movement out of the United States really casts a pall over him, right?
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
Even if there aren't facts to substantiate the fact that he's working for the Chinese intel services or later the Russians, just that sheer movement makes it harder for Poitras and Greenwald to kind of defend him.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And in this case, so he basically has gone to his supervisor at the NSA facility in Hawaii, says he needs to be away from work for what he'll say is a couple of weeks to receive treatment for epilepsy, which has kind of been an ongoing medical problem for him throughout his career.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
And then he basically, you know, that quote I read up front says nothing to his girlfriend about the true purpose for his trip, packs his bags, takes all these documents and goes to Hong Kong. That's right.
The Rest Is Classified
45. The Leak That Changed The World: America Exposed (Ep 3)
He has taken really via bulk downloads and some kind of fairly ingenious methods of sneaking information out of his NSA office in Hawaii, this bunker beneath the pineapple field. He's taken out... a trove of about 1.5 million documents, a variety of internal databases. And he's now at a point where he is figuring out how does he get this information out to the world?
The Rest Is History
564. The Great Northern War: The Battle of the Baltic (Part 1)
I'm David McCloskey, former CIA analyst turned spy novelist. And I'm Gordon Carrera, national security journalist. Together, we're the hosts of another Goal Hanger show, The Rest is Classified, and we bring you brilliant stories from the world of spies.
The Rest Is History
564. The Great Northern War: The Battle of the Baltic (Part 1)
It was 2011 when Snowden shocked the world by revealing that the American government was bulk collecting data on its own citizens and even spying on our allies.
The Rest Is History
564. The Great Northern War: The Battle of the Baltic (Part 1)
We will take you through the whole story from Snowden's early career in the CIA and the NSA to his life in exile in Russia.
The Rest Is History
564. The Great Northern War: The Battle of the Baltic (Part 1)
I'm David McCloskey, former CIA analyst turned spy novelist. And I'm Gordon Carrera, national security journalist. Together, we're the hosts of another Goalhanger show, The Rest is Classified, and we bring you brilliant stories from the world of spies. Here's that clip we mentioned earlier on. June 5th, 2013, this first article drops, and it's a massive one.
The Rest Is History
564. The Great Northern War: The Battle of the Baltic (Part 1)
There is a... tremendous gap between the understanding of this program, I think, inside the upper reaches of Congress and the intelligence community in the White House and what the American people think is happening. And that's where this article is such a bombshell because Americans prior to this, ordinary people, did not have an understanding that any of this was authorized. Exactly.
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
He absolutely is. So one of the presenters is a former CIA analyst who now writes spy novels, and that's David McCloskey. But the man who is also presenting it, a man very close to my heart, is Gordon Carrera.
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
uh so bbc security correspondent but more germainly massive enthusiast for pigeons who first alerted me to the massive role that pigeons have played in history you will then remember i nagged you for days weeks months was it a year no there was no nagging required to do a whole episode on pigeons which i think everyone would agree was a complete triumph i bargained them down from a series
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
And Gordon alerted us to the pigeon gap, the fact that China is way ahead of us when it comes to pigeons, pigeon communications. And it'd be interesting to find out from him whether he thinks that we've managed to close the pigeon gap. But more germainly, Gordon, welcome to the show and congratulations on The Rest Is Classified. Clearly, both of you were massive experts on the world of espionage.
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
But how did you come to find yourselves doing this podcast? Gordon
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
So after your virtual visit, Amazon will deliver your prescriptions directly to your door.
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
Because, Gordon, I guess the... The question is, does spying matter? Does it influence history? And for so long, the ability to answer that question has been locked up in archives or governed by the Official Secrets Act. But that's slightly changing, isn't it? And I guess that you and David, of all the people in the world, are the best qualified to tease that question out.
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
So you're going to have Alistair Campbell as a guest on your show.
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
As touches our own podcast, of course, we all know and love you as a great enthusiast for the role of pigeons in espionage. Can we just end by asking you, is Britain closing the pigeon gap?
The Rest Is History
Russian Spies, Pigeons, and The Rest Is Classified…
Maybe the rest is classified could become a great campaigning podcast. Campaigning podcast, yeah.