Juror
Appearances
Serialously with Annie Elise
251: Lori Vallow on Dateline, Teen Found Dismembered After Social Media Meetup, Karen Read Updates, and More!
So we all raised our hands in terms of a vote, and we voted on that first count that we all agreed not guilty. Unfortunately, at that time, we did not fill out any of the paperwork there, nor sign it. So we were under the understanding that each
Serialously with Annie Elise
251: Lori Vallow on Dateline, Teen Found Dismembered After Social Media Meetup, Karen Read Updates, and More!
charge could not be treated separately and so we continued to deliberate despite the fact that we had agreed on two of the counts as not guilty and the second count was was count three and and the same process where i guess the four person is asking for a vote and everyone raised their hands And everybody agreed, not guilty for those two charges. That's correct.
Serialously with Annie Elise
251: Lori Vallow on Dateline, Teen Found Dismembered After Social Media Meetup, Karen Read Updates, and More!
So we didn't check the box on the verdict slip because we were still deliberating on the second charge of involuntary manslaughter. And that continued with deliberation. We did send out notes asking for clarification. But unfortunately, we did not ask the question at the time, should we treat each charge individually and separately?
Serialously with Annie Elise
251: Lori Vallow on Dateline, Teen Found Dismembered After Social Media Meetup, Karen Read Updates, and More!
what the rules were when it was time to fill out the verdict slip and and determine and let everyone know where you were in these deliberations i so what one of the big things that happened was we all agreed and voted and we kind of not came back to any of those charges we never revisited them because we had already voted on them And then we kept on debating on that second charge.
Serialously with Annie Elise
251: Lori Vallow on Dateline, Teen Found Dismembered After Social Media Meetup, Karen Read Updates, and More!
And because we kept on debating on that second charge and deliberating, that kind of got us caught off guard at the end in terms of how to respond to that and whether to ask. There was a couple of us who did clearly indicate that maybe we should ask about treating each charge independently, but the majority overruled and essentially we were left to believe that it needed to be all or nothing.