Deputy Steve Kivy

She had been gone a little over 24 hours. Those are crucial hours, aren't they? Yes, they are. All we really had was that she went out for a jog and never came home.

She had been gone a little over 24 hours. Those are crucial hours, aren't they? Yes, they are. All we really had was that she went out for a jog and never came home.

You'd never investigated a murder before?

You'd never investigated a murder before?

I mean, that was a huge role in ICE.

I mean, that was a huge role in ICE.

She had been gone a little over 24 hours, but reported missing maybe 12. Those are crucial hours, aren't they? Yes.

She had been gone a little over 24 hours, but reported missing maybe 12. Those are crucial hours, aren't they? Yes.

She was supposed to be at work, but she didn't show up for work. So that pushes us back until the prior evening. And the best we could tell was around 7 p.m. she had a text to her mother saying, saying she was going to go for a jog or something and then maybe come over for dinner. So that's your starting point, 7 p.m.?

She was supposed to be at work, but she didn't show up for work. So that pushes us back until the prior evening. And the best we could tell was around 7 p.m. she had a text to her mother saying, saying she was going to go for a jog or something and then maybe come over for dinner. So that's your starting point, 7 p.m.?

Why was she staying in that house? Dalton was out of town working, so Molly had to stay there to let the dogs out. She was essentially dog-sitting.

Why was she staying in that house? Dalton was out of town working, so Molly had to stay there to let the dogs out. She was essentially dog-sitting.

They basically give us a tour of the house. And they say, look, Molly's wallet's here. All her clothes are still here. We look for kicked-in doors, signs of a scuffle inside the house. The house was exactly the way it was supposed to look.

They basically give us a tour of the house. And they say, look, Molly's wallet's here. All her clothes are still here. We look for kicked-in doors, signs of a scuffle inside the house. The house was exactly the way it was supposed to look.

How'd she know it was Molly? Because she's a hairdresser and she cut Molly's hair and she gave a pretty good description of what Molly was wearing. Black running shorts, a pink sports bra. She said she could see her ponytail bouncing. It was our first real definitive timestamp.

How'd she know it was Molly? Because she's a hairdresser and she cut Molly's hair and she gave a pretty good description of what Molly was wearing. Black running shorts, a pink sports bra. She said she could see her ponytail bouncing. It was our first real definitive timestamp.

Or was she lying injured beside the road? Ditches in July in Brooklyn are waist to chest high in grass. Corn is 8 to 10 feet high on both sides of the road. So if you wanted to hide something, you wouldn't have to try that hard. You could hide 100 bodies along that road and they'd be hard to find.

Or was she lying injured beside the road? Ditches in July in Brooklyn are waist to chest high in grass. Corn is 8 to 10 feet high on both sides of the road. So if you wanted to hide something, you wouldn't have to try that hard. You could hide 100 bodies along that road and they'd be hard to find.

I remember seeing trucks with boats, canoes, that kind of thing behind them. They were going to search waterways, that sort of thing.

I remember seeing trucks with boats, canoes, that kind of thing behind them. They were going to search waterways, that sort of thing.