Menu
Sign In Pricing Add Podcast
Podcast Image

Up First from NPR

Plane Crash Latest, German Far Right, Nuclear Testing

Fri, 31 Jan 2025

Description

Cockpit recordings have been recovered from the jet involved in a collision just outside of Washington, DC, a German far-right party is participating in mainstream politics for the first time since World War Two and researchers are studying nuclear weapons at an underground facility in Nevada.Want more comprehensive analysis of the most important news of the day, plus a little fun? Subscribe to the Up First newsletter.Today's episode of Up First was edited by Denice Rios, Ryland Barton, Gisele Grayson, Janaya Williams and Alice Woelfle. It was produced by Ziad Buchh, Nia Dumas, Claire Murashima and Chris Thomas. We get engineering support from Arthur Laurent and our technical director is Stacey Abbott. Our executive producer is Kelley Dickens. Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoicesNPR Privacy Policy

Audio
Transcription

2.861 - 8.389 Michelle Martin

We're starting to learn the identities of crew members on board the flights that collided just outside Washington, D.C.

0
💬 0

8.789 - 13.576 A. Martinez

Cockpit recordings from the jet have also been recovered. What can they tell investigators about why this happened?

0
💬 0

13.816 - 33.834 Michelle Martin

I'm Michelle Martin, that's A. Martinez, and this is Up First from NPR News. The German parliament passed a motion to restrict immigration by turning back asylum seekers at the border. It narrowly passed with the support of the country's extremist far-right party. Lawmakers' cooperation with them broke a long-standing taboo against working with the far-right.

0
💬 0

34.174 - 37.717 Michelle Martin

What does it mean that these extremists are now participating in mainstream politics?

0
💬 0

38.077 - 61.606 A. Martinez

And we pay a visit to a top-secret lab underneath the Nevada desert where nuclear weapons are tested and studied. Stay with us. We've got all the news you need to start your day. Federal investigators have retrieved the cockpit voice and flight data recorders from the American Airlines jet that collided with an Army helicopter Wednesday night.

0
💬 0

61.946 - 69.153 Michelle Martin

The crash, which occurred over the Potomac River, killed 67 people. We're also beginning to learn the identities of some of the crew on those aircraft.

0
💬 0

69.593 - 77.241 A. Martinez

NPR's Frank Langfitt has been following this story. Frank, so what will investigators be hoping to find out from the black boxes of that regional jet?

0
💬 0

77.907 - 91.95 Frank Langfitt

Yeah, A, I think the final conversations in the cockpit, obviously before the two aircraft collided, they'll also be able to see about the plane's performance, data points, and including, and I think this is really important, the altitude of the plane leading up to and at the time of the collision.

0
💬 0

92.25 - 113.844 Frank Langfitt

It's not yet clear how these two aircraft, who are supposed, of course, to pass at a safe distance, how they ended up in the same place at the same time. Of course, also going to need the Army Black Hawk black box to be able to compare. And a question that's really coming up, I think, particularly yesterday, talking to people at the NTSB is, was that helicopter on the right flight path?

0
💬 0

114.264 - 121.871 Frank Langfitt

The Black Hawk's recorder, as far as we know right now, is still in the river. But the National Transportation Safety Board, they're very confident they'll retrieve it.

0
💬 0

122.131 - 122.472 A. Martinez

Okay.

0
💬 0

122.792 - 144.527 Frank Langfitt

What do we know about the crew of the American Airlines jet? Yeah, we've got some confirmations here. The pilot was Jonathan Campos. He was 34. The first officer, a man named Sam Lilly in his late 20s, both based in Charlotte, really avid flyers. And Lilly is a second generation pilot. His father, Tim, used to fly for Air Wisconsin. And writing on Facebook yesterday, he said,

0
💬 0

144.887 - 158.759 Frank Langfitt

Tim Lilly wrote that Sam's career had been going very well, and he was engaged to be married in the fall. And he wrote this. He said, now it hurts so bad, I can't even cry myself to sleep. Now, later today, we should learn the identities of the three service members who were crewing the Blackhawk.

0
💬 0

159.751 - 172.199 A. Martinez

Frank, there are reports that the Federal Aviation Administration has said that the controller handling helicopters was also instructing planes. That's a job normally done by two people. So did federal investigators have anything to say about that?

0
💬 0

172.22 - 191.114 Frank Langfitt

Yeah, this was an FAA report that's been quoted by a number of news sources. NTSB, this is one of the board members, a guy named Todd Inman spoke yesterday, and he said they had not reviewed any specific reports about the controllers, but said, of course, as a matter of course, you know, you're going to be looking at what was going on in the control room and with the controllers.

0
💬 0

191.154 - 191.855 Frank Langfitt

This is what he said.

0
💬 0

192.295 - 202.62 Todd Inman

Our investigators are continuing to pull all that information. They're personnel records or files, where they were at, whether they were fatigued. All that information will be part of that investigative process.

0
💬 0

203.441 - 211.063 Frank Langfitt

And, you know, A, that's not ideal, but analysts say it's also not unusual and not necessarily dangerous, depending on how much traffic is going on at the time.

0
💬 0

211.69 - 214.812 A. Martinez

So today, another day of searching. What are people hoping to find out today?

0
💬 0

215.092 - 230.099 Frank Langfitt

Yeah, I mean, just more information. The NTSB yesterday down at Reagan National, during the press conference, they didn't say very much. And they're planning another briefing today. And typically, it's the second day where you learn a bit more. Yesterday was just the first day the team was on the ground. And

0
💬 0

230.459 - 248.953 Frank Langfitt

I'm actually looking at photos right now of NTSB workers opening up those black boxes from the airliner. And federal investigators, what they're really emphasizing is they want to be really careful about confirming facts before they pass them on. And there should be a preliminary report on this accident. It should be completed in about 30 days.

0
💬 0

248.973 - 265.013 A. Martinez

30 days. Okay. That's NPR's Frank Langford. Frank, thank you. Good to talk to you. What started as a motion to do more to restrict immigration to Germany has now become something bigger.

0
💬 0

265.394 - 277.863 Michelle Martin

It has erupted into a fierce national debate over the degree to which the country should allow its most extreme political elements into mainstream politics. And at the center of this debate is the man who is the frontrunner to become Germany's next chancellor.

0
💬 0

278.223 - 284.108 A. Martinez

NPR's Berlin correspondent Rob Schmitz joins us to discuss this. So set the scene for us, Rob. How did all this start?

0
💬 0

284.729 - 300.002 Rob Schmitz

So this all started with a parliamentary motion to restrict immigration from Friedrich Merz. He's the head of the Christian Democratic Union, a center-right party that's ahead in the polls and will likely win the most votes in Germany's election next month. And that means Merz will likely be Germany's next chancellor.

0
💬 0

300.422 - 302.624 A. Martinez

All right. So what did he do in parliament this week?

0
💬 0

303.131 - 321.204 Rob Schmitz

Well, he brought forth a motion to further restrict immigration to Germany, and this comes on the heels of recent deadly attacks committed by migrants. Now, on the face of it, there was nothing off about Merz's motion in Parliament about this, but it was how he was going to pass this motion that really upset much of Parliament and many Germans.

0
💬 0

321.544 - 323.926 A. Martinez

Upset. So what was so upsetting to lawmakers about that?

0
💬 0

324.548 - 344.672 Rob Schmitz

Well, none of the mainstream parties were interested in voting with Merz's party on this proposal. But there was one party that was very keen to join him, and that's the AFD, the Alternative for Germany Party, which is considered by Germany's political establishment as an extremist right-wing party. The AFD has advocated deporting all Germans with a migration background.

0
💬 0

344.712 - 351.734 Rob Schmitz

Some of its members use Nazi slogans. And the party is under domestic surveillance for the threat that it poses to Germany's democracy.

0
💬 0

352.014 - 358.755 A. Martinez

So, Rob, just a guess here, but because of Germany's history in World War II, I'd imagine that a party like AFD is probably worrying a lot of people.

0
💬 0

359.266 - 378.383 Rob Schmitz

Yeah, that's right. And since World War II, there's been a consensus among Germany's mainstream political parties that extremist parties must never be allowed in government again. And when the AfD first gained popularity a decade ago, Merz's party and Germany's other mainstream parties made a path to never cooperate with the AfD. This was called the firewall.

0
💬 0

378.904 - 396.168 Rob Schmitz

But now Merz is signaling that he's open to cooperating with the AfD on this immigration motion. And here's how he defended his decision. And he's saying here that the right decision does not become wrong because the wrong people have made it. The decision, he said, is still right.

0
💬 0

396.528 - 399.47 A. Martinez

OK, how are other mainstream parties responding to all this?

0
💬 0

400.23 - 418.559 Rob Schmitz

Lots of anger. As Merz defended himself, a yelling match began in Parliament and Chancellor Olaf Scholz finally took the podium. Here's what he said. Schultz said that three weeks ago, Merz promised never to cooperate with the AFD and voters trusted him. What are these words worth now, he asked.

0
💬 0

419.099 - 423.641 Rob Schmitz

Former Chancellor Angela Merkel, who's in the same party as Merz, also has criticized him for doing this.

0
💬 0

424.001 - 426.542 A. Martinez

Any indication of why Merz did this?

0
💬 0

427.162 - 440.332 Rob Schmitz

Well, there is an election in a few weeks and it's possible Merz is cooperating with the AFD on immigration because up to now, the AFD has owned this issue and it's led to high poll numbers. They're now in second place and Elon Musk has recently come out to support them.

0
💬 0

440.392 - 452.362 Rob Schmitz

So the logic goes if Merz's party can steal some of that spotlight, perhaps he can chip into that support and take some of those voters to his party. But many are blaming him for playing a dangerous game with Germany's democracy on this.

0
💬 0

452.816 - 456.998 A. Martinez

That's NPR's Berlin correspondent Rob Schmitz. Rob, thanks. Thanks.

0
💬 0

465.482 - 468.844 Michelle Martin

Nuclear weapons testing might seem like a relic of the Cold War.

0
💬 0

474.09 - 481.277 A. Martinez

But the world's major nuclear powers are eyeing each other with suspicion. Each believes the other might conduct a nuclear test soon.

0
💬 0

481.597 - 494.769 Michelle Martin

As all this is happening, NPR's Jeff Brumfield got an extraordinary look inside America's program to maintain its nuclear weapons. And he's with us now to tell us more about it. Jeff, good morning. Good morning. So just start out by telling us where you went and what you saw.

0
💬 0

495.249 - 520.506 Jeff Brumfield

Yeah, I went out to the Nevada National Security Site. It used to be the Nevada test site where America tested its nuclear warheads. That hasn't happened since the 1990s, but scientists are still studying nuclear weapons down there in a top-secret lab that's deep underground. To get there, you have to step into this mining elevator. And it drops you nearly a thousand feet below the desert.

0
💬 0

521.006 - 534.191 Jeff Brumfield

At the bottom is a network of tunnels that's been carved out of an ancient lake bed. David Funk is overseeing upgrades to the labs, and he told me these tunnels were originally dug for underground nuclear detonations.

0
💬 0

534.751 - 542.254 Unknown

Yeah, this was designed to be a nuclear test location originally, and now we do only subcritical experiments in this location.

0
💬 0

543.16 - 546.542 Michelle Martin

Okay, he said subcritical experiments. Jeff, what does that mean?

0
💬 0

547.102 - 571.598 Jeff Brumfield

Well, subcritical experiments are experiments that use nuclear weapons material like plutonium, but they don't trigger a runaway nuclear chain reaction. That's the reaction that gives bombs their incredible power. The data from these experiments is fed into supercomputers that calculate how nuclear weapons are doing. Basically, they're simulating blowing up nukes inside these supercomputers.

0
💬 0

572.583 - 579.786 Jeff Brumfield

Now, in the tunnels, I spoke to Don Haynes, a nuclear weapons scientist from Los Alamos National Lab. He says this whole system works.

0
💬 0

580.026 - 593.653 Don Haynes

They don't need to do a full system test of a weapon. Our assessment is that there are no system questions that would be answered by a test. that would be worth the expense and the effort and the time.

0
💬 0

594.194 - 601.218 Jeff Brumfield

But of course, Haynes is just a scientist. It's the politicians and generals who are going to decide whether the U.S. conducts another test.

0
💬 0

601.518 - 606.661 Michelle Martin

To that point, though, do we know what the Trump administration plans to do with regards to nuclear testing?

0
💬 0

607.561 - 628.796 Jeff Brumfield

So during the first Trump administration, there was some discussion of testing. And over the summer, his former national security advisor wrote that the U.S. should conduct a full nuclear test under Trump 2.0. And then there's Project 2025, a conservative agenda whose authors have close ties to Trump. It also says the president should have the option to do a test if he needs to.

0
💬 0

628.816 - 647.301 Jeff Brumfield

Well, Jeff, why would he need to? Well, as we just heard, the scientists don't need to test, but there may be political reasons. You know, other countries might threaten the U.S. with nuclear weapons or the president might need to display his resolve. And one way to do that would be to conduct a test. So what would be the consequences of a return to testing?

0
💬 0

647.821 - 657.585 Jeff Brumfield

Arms control experts say this would be a huge mistake for America. And the reason is kind of interesting. Here's Jamie Kwong with the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

0
💬 0

657.965 - 664.248 Jamie Kwong

The U.S. has a technical advantage locked in by this moratorium on nuclear testing.

0
💬 0

664.693 - 677.792 Jeff Brumfield

And that's because the U.S. has done well over a thousand nuclear tests, while China has only done 45. So China will gain a lot more knowledge from test 46 than the U.S. will from its next test.

0
💬 0

678.072 - 680.676 Michelle Martin

That is NPR's Jeff Brumfield. Jeff, thank you. Thank you.

0
💬 0

685.319 - 688.18 A. Martinez

And that's Up First for Friday, January 31st. I'm E. Martinez.

0
💬 0

688.22 - 696.444 Michelle Martin

And I'm Michelle Martin. And just a reminder, Up First airs on weekends, too. Ayesha Roscoe and Scott Simon will have the news. Look for it wherever you get your podcasts.

0
💬 0

696.824 - 714.753 A. Martinez

Today's episode of Up First was edited by Denise Rios, Rylan Barton, Giselle Grayson, Jenea Williams, and Alice Wolfley. It was produced by Ziad Butch, Nia Dumas, and Claire Murashim, also Chris Thomas. We get engineering support from Arthur Laurent, and our technical director is Stacey Abbott. Our executive producer is Kelly Dickens. Join us again.

0
💬 0

730.373 - 745.271 Unknown

Want to hear this podcast without sponsor breaks? Amazon Prime members can listen to Up First sponsor-free through Amazon Music. Or you can also support NPR's vital journalism and get Up First Plus at plus.npr.org. That's plus.npr.org.

0
💬 0

747.481 - 758.45 Ron Rudson

This message comes from NPR sponsor, Sotva. Founder and CEO Ron Rudson shares why Sotva sales associates are focused on finding the perfect mattress for their customers.

0
💬 0

759.051 - 780.013 Unknown

At Sotva, we have a 365-day home trial. Why would we want to rush you or try to push you into something that's not right for you? We want to make sure that we guide you to the right mattress. Our team is always available to be helpful, to make sure you make the right choice. To learn more, go to saatva.com slash NPR.

0
💬 0
Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.