Stuart McGill
Appearances
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then I took another four students who had the ropes on the next coffee can and then on the next coffee can. And then I'd say, okay, group, flex the spine forward. So the students on the front would pull a little bit, but the guy on top had to pull more than the next coffee can, and then the next coffee can a little bit less, vice versa.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, thank you, Professor Huberman. You know this, but I'm going to mention this for the listeners. You have done a great deed in changing the behavior of many people, myself included, and my family. It's not the easiest thing to do. because there's always the critics, but you have done a tremendous service. And I thank you for that as well.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And I thank you personally because you've improved my life and hopefully I'll have a few more years to enjoy it, but thank you.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
The people on the other side had to pay out the rope in sequence. And then I would say, okay, now let's twist a little bit. Anyway, you could imagine it was impossible to control. And then I took out the tennis balls And I put in what was a disc, a big round cylindrical piece of foam rubber. All of a sudden that added stiffness. So now, because the body uses stiffness as the control parameter.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Now we've added control in that the foam rubber would create a buffer. And as the deviation in motion occurred, the foam rubber would add more resistance. So it was an automatic control. And that's what a shock absorber does on a car. It has an elastic element plus the damper, but it's the elastic element. And we're going to talk about stiffness and stability, I hope.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
that really creates the control. So that's why we have evolved discs. It's highly efficient. I can bend the spine to tie my shoe, but if I have to carry home these days, heavy shopping bags, I need stiffness of that flexible rod so it doesn't collapse.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Or years ago, I might have been carrying home an animal for dinner and I needed those discs to provide the stiffness in a very economical way and in a way that didn't create stress concentrations the way ball and socket joints would. So that's an evolutionary necessity.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Also when we look at spines, there are the column of vertebrae with the intervening discs, but behind them there's two more joints and those are called facet joints and they guide motion. Those facet joints have a variety of angles. They can have open angles which allow you to twist. So if you took a group of golfers, could you imagine if they had facet angles like this, you can't twist.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If the angle is orientated fore and aft, you can't twist. And you won't find if you're dealing with a group of professional golfers, you'll find they all have open facet joints. Is that genetic? It's absolutely 100% genetic.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Now, interestingly enough, when you arch back, when the facet joints are orientated open, as I'm describing, when you arch back, one pushes hard on the other, like shingles on a roof. that stresses a bone called the pars bone.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And gymnasts, for example, get a very typical fracture pattern called a spondylolisthesis, which is a fracture of that bone and then the spine shifts a little bit at that joint. I'm just finishing rehabbing a pro tennis player who had the same thing after they tried to have too much range of motion in their serve, the coach gave them
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
excessive extension to try and put more miles an hour on the ball, but it didn't suit the spine. And they ended up having a stress fracture.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
That's a huge question, and there's many more variables to consider. But I will say that when we are rehabilitating an athlete or just a person to get back to work, they're an occupational athlete. We take all of this into consideration. So as you were describing your sister arching back, A, I know she has plump discs, discs that are full of fluid to allow the mobility to take place in the discs.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I also know that if we looked at an x-ray from the side, you know the posterior spinous processes. If you run your thumb down the midline of a person's back... you will feel the bumps of bone up the middle of the spine. Those are the posterior spines. She will have a large space between each one when she's standing upright. So when she extends back, those spaces will,
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
come together and eventually the spines, what we call it kissing spines. And it takes me back to some of the old Russian techniques for bench press. They would bench press with a huge arch in their back.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then other people would say, oh, well, I'm going to try and mimic that particular bench press technique because it allows you to get much more force out of latissimus dorsi, a stiffer back, and you get a different force vector and actually more effective force on the bar.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They didn't realize that when we work with a person who has a huge arch, they have big spaces between those spinous processes. And if you don't have those big spaces, you are going to crush the interspinous ligaments, which naturally are between those spaces. And you will now fire off a whole set of new problems.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So what is a mechanical advantage for one person is a mechanical disadvantage for another. Do you follow? So all of this matters. Going back to the... disc being a fabric of layer upon layer of collagen strands. Typically, the disc is about 80% type 1 collagen. That is the stiff strength collagen. about another 20% is elastic collagen, type two.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But there's types three through 10 that bind those collagen fibers together. That's where there's a much greater degree of genetic variability. So there are some people who can get away with doing mini sit-ups. They have a slender spine and they have the type of binding collagen that holds all those fibers together.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But if I wanted to work these fibers of my shirt apart, get them to delaminate, I would create repeated stress strain reversals. The resistance of that fabric depends on the stuff holding the fibers together. So there will be binding fibers there. That's where the genetic variance lies in many people. So even there, the person's resilience to repeatedly doing a bending drill
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
is determined by your parents to some degree, both in the size, the collagen type three through 10 makeups.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
The answer is yes, but it's a very limited yes. So if I can set the stage and give some context here. Every system in the body requires stress for optimal health. Think of the cardiovascular system, the musculoskeletal system, the endocrine system, even the psychological system. It needs stress to create adaptation for robustness. but you cannot cross what's known as the tipping point.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Because if you do, you start building cumulative trauma of some form, whether it's emotional trauma psychologically, or it's cumulative stress at the tissue level, at the level of the cell. we have to talk about those tipping points. We've got to define where they are, try and expand them, adapt them, but don't cross them.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So with that context now, we can talk about a person's suitability for the stresses on different parts of their body associated with different sports. We can talk about the rate at which the adaptation occurs. the amount of deloads and rest that are required, all of these things are genetically influenced. The way that they perform the movement is going to move the stress concentration.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Here's an interesting demonstration for you. If you go to the Olympics and look at the podium winners of a javelin thrower, They look identical. Do you think the swimmers look like the javelin throwers? No, they don't.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Yeah. Let me just give another very... poignant example of that. Consider a sport that has three very separate demands of the athlete. Consider a triathlete. The triathlete has to swim a certain distance, then they bike a certain distance, and then they run a certain distance. Have you ever known a person who comes out of the lake or the pool, whatever it is, first winning the triathlon?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It doesn't work that way. What suited them to be a fish? Fast in water. They have to be somewhat floppy in the ankles because they're creating a fish's fin. Longer in the torso. consider a power lifter performing a butterfly stroke. It wouldn't look very pretty. Then they get on the bike where they have to stiffen to stiffen the core. I don't know if you know bike design. Well, I'm sure you do.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You're paying for stiffness of the frame. That's what a really elite- I did not know that. Yeah. So when a person pushes on the pedal, the frame doesn't flex because that would be an energy leak. You pay for a very stiff frame. So every ounce of force that you apply to the crank handle to propel you forward propels you forward instead of being wasted and bending the frame.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
The same way the cyclist will lock in on the bike, they'll squeeze the saddle between their legs, lock into the bars, lock their core down so that when they create power through the hips and through the legs, it's transferred to the power. It isn't transferred to bending their willowy body. That is very different from the neurology and the mechanics of a swimmer. Now let's run.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
To run, the most efficient runners... store and recover elastic energy in tuned springs. A wonderful book to read is The Lost Art of Running by Shane Benzie, who studied the Kenyan runners and how they store and recover elastic energy with each stride, almost the same way as a kangaroo would.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
A kangaroo is more efficient when it hops versus plodding along using eccentric concentric muscle contraction. So again, the polar opposite of a swimmer. It's a very tuned stiffness. The most efficient runners for the third leg of the triathlon pre-stiffen. they have a pre-contraction of the muscle.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So when the foot hits the ground, they're already storing the elastic elements and they get that back for free. But if the springs were not tuned and they'd stretched away their muscles just to be passive elements, which serves them very well in the swimming element, think of doing a pogo jump. So you're just pogoing through the ankles now. If you had no tone in the legs,
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
you would just flop into the ground and you would have to use concentric eccentric muscle contraction. But if you stiffened too much, you're now a piece of iron and you won't be able to jump either, but you'll get a beautiful resonance, a beautiful pogo when you have the tuning just right. So when a muscle contracts, it creates force.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
We all know this, but people don't appreciate you're also tuning the stiffness. If I maximally contract my muscles, I can't move. So athletes have to tune muscle if they're impacting athletes, but they also have to pulse and relax.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Pulse, we were talking about Mike Tyson before the podcast today and the mechanics of how he pulses and then he's got to relax to get closing velocity of the fist to the opponent. And then when his fist hits the opponent, he turns to granite. And it is just such an awesome experience to feel that a little bit.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It's one of the joys of my life working with elite athletes to feel their athleticism, but then dissect it down as to how they do it. So there's a lot in that, but that lesson from the triathlete really shows us how... You can't be good at everything. There's always a trade-off with athleticism and the genetic part.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then of course, in the appropriate training to optimize and express that genetic gift through technique, through technique. So some athletes are very loose. Some athletes are very tight. Some are very elastic. You won't hit a golf ball 330 yards if you're not an elastic athlete. You'll notice if you measure a golfer who can hit 330 yards, they don't test very strong.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They have a beautiful, tuned, elastic body. You can almost see it if you've worked with enough of them. There's a smoothness to the muscle. So underneath the skin is a fascial net. Someone who can throw a baseball 110, 115, 120 miles an hour will be the same. But now you have a very asymmetric elastic effect.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
The answer is I don't know. But I know people will say, oh, well, this professor, he's avoiding the question. And I'm not going to do that. So I'm going to tell you how I find the answer. And it's through assessment. And I'm glad we're getting back to back pain, by the way, because it's my real, the cornerstone of my expertise. Our assessment is very comprehensive.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It starts out by me simply asking the person, tell me your story. And some people never tell me about their pain when I ask them to tell me their story. They will be telling me about their family life and the pressures that they have to still go to work because they have two kids in school or four kids in school.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Or they might tell me about the passions that they have, or they might tell me about their goals. So the goals are the beginning of answering your question, Andrew. We all know people who aren't suited for a certain occupation or they aren't suited or they... I'll take myself for example. I had a high school careers counselor tell my father, well, McGill, he's not really suited academically.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
He should go to trade school. And so I registered for plumbing school.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, I think I would have been okay as a plumber.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But anyway, my point in that is, what are the goals? Then the assessment... I'm paying attention to the person's learning style. How are we going to coach them? And then we get down to the details of their pain. What's the nature of the pain? Is it when they get out of bed in the morning? Is it associated with a certain activity? Is it associated with certain motions, postures, or loads?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Try and hone, does the pain change? Does it start out on one side of the back and then later in the day it's in the left glute or does it go down to your right toes? All of these things are telling me about the stability of the pain. It's giving me clues on what I'm going to assess. Then we go and assess them. And it begins with what we call provocative testing.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I'm purposefully provoking their pain. If I can provoke their pain, I've nailed the mechanic. If I can't provoke it, it's not mechanical. Okay, well, that tells me something now. So now I'm starting to see... I know what their job is. I know what sport it is they want to do. I know enough about that job and sport that I know the physical demands. I know the psychological demands.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Do they have what's required of the job or sport? And then I test that. if it triggers their pain, we have a problem. So now we have to focus the trainings very specifically because people do not have infinite training capacity. They only have so much. And when you're hurt, you have even less. So we try and focus on things
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
that are going to make a difference to enable them to have the ability to meet those specific demands that we've identified. So do you see how it's a long-winded answer, but I know how to get there to know how to train them. So now that we've recognized the very specific nature of their pain pathway, and it may be something that's going through the linkage.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
In other words, when they run, I could give you an example of if we put a group of Canadian hockey players on an elliptical trainer, they don't do very well because typical of the sport, the hockey players tend to get stiffer in the hips. It's the way they are. They skate a little bit flexed and they carry all the heavy skates and heavy equipment down the legs. They get stiffer in the hips.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
When they go on the elliptical, their hips don't have the range of motion and their spine and pelvis gyrates with every rotation on the elliptical trainer. The elliptical gives them back pain if they already have motion triggered back pain. We take another group who has mobile hips. They do very well on elliptical trainers. The stress doesn't go into their backs.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So now do you see why I know why one group does well with ellipticals, the other group does not? I know why one group who they, I'll give them a lateral shear test, which is basically a bear hug. I pull their pelvis towards me as I hook down their shoulder in my armpit. So I'm shearing their spine laterally. If that triggers their pain, exactly. I had a...
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
pro hockey player the other day, I gave him the lateral shear test and he had a right-sided flash of pain going around his right flank. It exactly replicated the pain. I just found with precision the mechanism. Okay, what's the antidote? I put my fingers into his oblique muscles and I said, push my fingers out. And he did it too hard. And he says, oh no, that hurts even more.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Okay, dial it back a bit. Tune what we're trying to achieve here. Fight me just a little bit. I repeated the formerly offensive test. The symptom was gone. So now I'm getting more precision on knowing what I need to do. he was doing the Palof Press. The Palof Press is a long lever exercise.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So you take a load, usually with a cable or a band that's held laterally, and you increase the length of the lever, which you have to resist because it's trying to- So you punch it out from the body. Yeah, you try and, it's causing you to twist, but it also creates a tremendous sheer load on your spine. That was triggering his pain. So we took out the Palof Press, which for him right now,
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
is replicating his symptoms. But if you're playing in the NHL, you should be able to do a palloff press. You follow? Yeah. Yeah. It's a requirement of the rigors of professional hockey, but he can't do it now. So this is informing the programming that we're going to do.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Every person that comes to us comes with back pain. So initially we avoid it. We can have a neurological discussion if you like. We can have a biomechanical discussion or we can have a psychological discussion. We can take it in the framework of any of those if we like. If the pain is causing a sensitization, I'm going to use the example here of stubbing your toe.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You stub your toe once, okay, well, it hurts a bit and the pain goes away fairly quickly. But if every day you stubbed your toe, you would increase the sensitivity so that you don't have to stub it anymore. All you have to do is lightly touch that sensitized toe and you are going to have a maladaptive heightened response. So if we keep creating pain on that toe, it will never get better.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So we have to start a desensitization wind down, which is tissue based, but it's also neurologically based as well. And so because everyone comes to us with pain, We work very hard to hack our way around it. So let's say sitting causes their pain. All right, we'll find out that when we do a sitting test, if they sit slouched, that causes their pain. When they sit upright, their pain goes away.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So I will give them a lumbar support, which I'm just happening to use now. I had to sit on an airplane for five hours yesterday coming to see you.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
and this allows me to not get back pain on the airplane while I'm sitting because if I sit flexed for five hours, I will have a grumpy back, and I won't feel like when I get into the hotel to go for a walk and train a bit because that's what we have to do to create a stress below the tipping point to optimize health. So it's the same thing in putting together the program. First of all,
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
know the cause and try and eliminate it. So we'll teach them, you know, we spend a lot of time with spine hygiene. We teach them how to hip hinge or squat. We teach them how to lunge, how to get to the floor. We teach them how to roll without twisting their spine into pain, but using their ball and socket joints. We teach them how to do a baby's crawl.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
which eliminates the torso twisting, which in their current state will offend the sensitized pain trigger.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It's so humbling to take a world record holding athlete. and humble them right back. As you know, I've had the current holder of the world's all-time record squat, Brian Carroll. And Brian and I have written a book together, so I can use his name. What's the squat record? 1,306 pounds, if you can believe that. Down to parallel. Down to parallel. No other human has done that.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
That was four years ago now. No one's replicated it.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Yeah. So he's putting on an exoskeleton of stiffness. But I want to come back to how humbling it was to have someone who already held world records in squatting in two different weight categories, and I had to show him how to get off the toilet. But that's another story. And we both laugh at this now. But that was what pain had done.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Pain had corrupted his movement patterns and he forgot how to squat, but he held the world record. That's how corruptive pain is to the neurological engram. And we can talk about inhibition and facilitation and all of the things. I mean, I'd love to have that conversation because I know who I'm sitting with.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
All right. You're not letting me off the hook, which is fine. So I've worked with competitors who compete in strongman and they can carry and walk with a thousand pounds on their shoulders. It's called the super yoke. Another client of ours who held the World Wilkes score in the IPF, International Powerlifting Federation, where they do not lift out of a monolith.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They take the bar off a squat rack and they have to step back. And that is, if you don't have enough lateral strength and control in your torso, that's when you become hurt. Not during the squat, it's during the walkout. So it's a very different feat of strength. So you're very astute to say lifting from a monolith is a different athleticism and strength distribution.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
than an IPF style where they lift off a rack and have to walk it out. So you're standing on one leg. So can you imagine a thousand pounds coming down your axial spine, down your midline, it hits your pelvis, and then it has to shear across the pelvis and go down the stance leg as you're stepping back with the right.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So it requires tremendous strength to hold the pelvic platform up on the swing leg side. And so that is a tremendous core strength component.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, you want to be built like Blaine Sumner, who's another one of our... clients. I've worked with Blaine for quite a number of years.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
We time the clients. I see one in the morning and one in the afternoon and there are three hour appointments. So I know when they're coming. I watch them get out of the car if I can. And that's when the assessment starts. But just to go back to the dogs, my sister's a vet, her husband's a vet and her daughter's in vet training. So we have these conversations all the time.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Do you know she's already made an assessment of that dog on how it's going to behave when she injects it or has to do a rectal exam or whatnot on what dog or breed? And even in cats, which ones she's going to muzzle because she's usually right on who's going to get bit. Yeah. And interestingly as well, it's how the dog feeds off the owner.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And she can look at the owner and usually determine how the dog is going to behave. So talk about the psychosocial milieu around dog behavior. Absolutely. Going back to your question, when a person walks in. So I've had, have I had a gold medalist in sprints? Yes, I have from the Olympics. I've had a silver medalist. I've had just about every athlete that you can.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then a person walks in off the street, all with back pain. In your mind's eye, conjure up the image of a good sprinter. Do you think they have a flat lower back or do you think they have a lot of lordosis, which is an extension hollow in their low back? A sprinter now, what will they have?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Yeah, he was 200 meters, wasn't he? 200 and 400 meters?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, think of some of the sprinters now, the 100 meter men and women, you will find, They have a lot more lordosis than the distance runners. Yeah, they have a lot. And what that does, I'll just explain the running mechanics here for a minute. So if you're running along, you have a center of mass. You have to bias the force under your feet behind the center of mass to propel you forward.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Because if it's in front of the center of mass, you're actually breaking, which wouldn't win you a gold medal. So footfall has to... occur behind the center of mass, and then you get a very brief period of time to create an extensor pulse and then recover the leg.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If you can pre-turn the pelvis with a lot of lordosis in the spine, you get much more power development behind the center of mass through the extensor range. If you have a flat back, it's difficult now. You've just shortened up the range that you can pulse into propulsive force as a sprinter.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Yeah. But you'll notice it's very difficult for a sprinter to kick high. So I look at these different forms in the combat athletes. If you look at someone who can kick high in a roundhouse, they will tend to have a flatter back. So combat athletes tend to have a flatter back.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Going back to the runners, you'll notice that the Michael Johnsons and the runners with more distance have a flatter spine. They're more upright and they're tuning that ability to store and recover elastic energy. Where the sprinter out of the blocks, it's horsepower. It's concentric and eccentric muscle pulsing.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But anyway, there would be an example since you mentioned it with running, the style of running, the event. Running isn't running. Running is very different. And again, look at the podium winners of the sprinters versus the 10,000 meters. Very different architecture.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I'm going to go back to the fact that they're coming to me with pain. We are going to figure out through the thorough assessment what triggers their pain. Most people, it's true, don't want ultimate performance. They're not being paid $10 million to be able to throw a fastball or something like that. They want to enjoy life. Let's say they love golf.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
My job is to get them sufficiently robust and out of pain to go and play recreational golf. So it becomes a moot point now, whether they have a willowy spine or not. I will look at their basic golf swing. if I can divide that up to just binary, some people are what we call twisters. They don't have a lot of hip mobility and they twist their spine.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So it's called the X factor in golf and they store and recover elastic energy. Again, it is an elastic athleticism. But the next person isn't so much a twister, they're a turner. They have what we call quick hips. So their hips turn and their spines don't sustain as much twist.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then we measure, well, when they impact the ball, if they have 100% violent lateral crunch, and then we measure them and assess them, and that turns out to be their pain trigger, what we do is we don't allow them to go to 100% in lateral crunch at impact. They go to 95%. And that just moved them off the tipping point. So they're not stubbing their toe or slamming into... the pain sensitizer.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It all comes back to the assessment.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If I can just add one, I don't want to interrupt, but this is a good juncture, Andrew. Then we get into the volume of exposure. So remember the tipping point. We can have somewhat of an offense to their former pain, but if we do it sparingly... That's another key.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So it isn't a matter of selecting the exercise sometimes as much as it is controlling the volume and then having a period of time off or a deload or whatnot. So it may simply be, I've got an athlete that comes to mind right now. In fact, I got an email. It wasn't an email. It was a WhatsApp message. Oh, I just won. Sorry. She's at an international tournament today and they play every day.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But in getting her back, it was a matter of we have to do these things that were former pain triggers, but control the volume. you can think of, again, combat athletes. Jiu-jitsu requires a lot of spine mobility. And typically, jiu-jitsu athletes get pain when they use too much spine mobility. What we do is we limit their training.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
In other words, they have the skill of jiu-jitsu, but they don't need to push the end range every day. Because if they do... They're in so much pain, they can't train. So we back off the volume. And I could tell you stories about professional football players. They were their strongest when they were in college. Their bodies can't take the heavy strength training once they get into the NFL.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They don't squat and deadlift what they used to. They're limiting the depth. They're pulling off blocks. The game changes and it's not what people think.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Yeah. I have a short attention span. Can I just add added value to that? Don't get hurt. Getting hurt is tremendously asymmetric. Let me, do you know the book by Taleb Nassim? Oh, Nassim Taleb.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Antifragile. Yeah. Oh, in Antifragile, he quotes our work. He quotes my Low Back Disorders book as an example of antifragile medicine. Interesting. Anyway, when you talk to Taleb, in an economic sense, If I gave you $100 to invest, if you had a 50% gain, you'd end up with 150 bucks. If you had a 50% loss, you'd end up with 50.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It's much more hurtful to lose 50 than the relative jolly you would get of gaining 50.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Right. And so it is so asymmetric with injury. Training, if you push, is taking a risk. You might gain a little bit in short-term resilience or short-term performance, but you have a chance of really screwing things up. And an injury is really asymmetrically harmful. So when we work with People and athletes, we really try and avoid injury because of the asymmetry of the consequence. Injury is bad.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
That's the first part that I wanted to say. The second part is people train hard and they feel the muscle burn and they talk about muscle, but they don't talk about their joints. And the key to long life is don't mess up your joints. You can train hard and build muscle, but muscle is adaptive and resilient. Joints are not so much.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And if you start messing those up when you're younger by training too hard, you'll find that, oh, I was training at this intensity because I wanted to be strong when I'm 70 and 80. They'll find that, no, their knees ache. They can't get down on their knees anymore. They have to crawl up a chair or a wall. Very sad picture. It is. Don't mess up your joints.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So that's an overarching principle of which the spine is one, obviously. But that's some wisdom with training intensely when you're young. Don't base the outcome on muscle. Think about the joints.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Let me give context before I define it as tightly as I can for you. Back pain is a symptom. So let's just change the topic for a moment and talk about leg pain. Can you imagine asking someone, well, could you give me an exercise or a prevention strategy for leg pain? Okay, so that sets the stage a little bit.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Right. Well, I'm very sympathetic to the overall sentiment of what you just described, but I think it's much more individual than that. You can take a younger person and drive them quite hard, as some trainers do, and they have success. a young person responds, they recover faster, et cetera. You try doing that to a 65 year old and you'll find that they don't recover as quickly.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They need many more deload and rest days. So if you go to 85%, you just committed to a five day rest. Well, maybe that's not wise. If you went to 50%, you only need one day of rest between. So do you see how you play and you optimize this? And it's like what we call tapering down an athlete. Or, you know, in my life, I have seasons. Up until two years ago, I rode snowmobiles hard in the winter.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Two years ago, I hit a rock at 100 miles an hour on a lake. I fractured my spine. You can spot the professor. So that was my passion. So my training would start in August. Every year, I'd get into shape to ride sleds fairly aggressively. I couldn't do it all year, Andrew. I'd become injured. So I would have a cycle of three months getting ready and then really have some fun.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But obviously I don't do that anymore. But my point in telling that story is I need much more information than just, okay, 85%. You may get away with that when you're 20 to 25. I don't think you're going to get away with that when you're 50, as an example. As we optimize performance in our clients, sometimes you got to leave a lot of gas in the tank because you want to train every other day.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Certainly if you do two days in a row, 85%, there's no way. So do you see what I mean? It depends on their age, their injury history, their genetics and their body type and all the rest of it. What are we actually pushing to 85%? Is it a distance on a run? Is it a deadlift weight?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
We're talking about a symptom for which there's a hundred or more different pathways and mechanisms there. So we've got to have a fairly comprehensive assessment now and understanding. to focus on the type of back pain, and then matching an appropriate intervention. I was listening to your new podcast with Andy Galpin this morning. The Perform podcast. The Perform podcast, yeah.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, I appreciate all what you've said. In my world, everyone has a back pain history. So it's always, it's the information that we gather from the assessment that guides our decision on how we're going to A, get them out of pain, build some base resilience, which is tuning their body, strategic mobility, strategic stability.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Now, one thing we haven't talked about is various types of pain and how yet that impacts on how we're going to approach their programming for life. You did a podcast with somebody. I can't remember what their name was, but it was a pain podcast. And you were developing this idea that if the... mechanism of their pain was really part of the changed engram.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They were traumatized at the time of the event, or maybe it was a history of sexual abuse or whatever. but I can detect that person almost always. I'll start to put my hands on them to feel, oh, is there any intelligence here? And they recoil. That's an abused person. That's a very characteristic response.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So you start putting together some of these reactions and you know that there's something deeper than an injury to a part of their spine.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Right. I love that podcast, by the way, because it's so consistent with what we've found and what we do. If a person has a It was just a mechanical exceeding of their tipping point and they now have some tissue damage. We address that by Creating a strategy that they don't move or load in a way to stress that. And we allow the injury to heal if we can.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And we should talk about whether the disc adapts or you have to manage it. But that's another very interesting topic to get into. But nonetheless. We are tuning their body with strategic mobility and stability, giving them core exercise, unleashing their hips and shoulders, et cetera. And we will have a reasonable level of success.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And we know, by the way, what our success is because uniquely we follow up with every patient we see to know if we were successful or not. But now we have that person, and I can think of many examples just to give a spectrum. Perhaps the person was in a car accident. They survived, but the person beside them who might've been their mother died.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And he said, I'm going to try and follow the three I's. And it was, I think, gather information, interpret the information, and then intervene. So it's the same kind of deal here. And of course, that's pan-intervention. medical condition, shall we say. So with that context, I'm going to answer it like this. What causes back pain?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So now they're carrying a hell of a lot of emotional trauma, guilt, trauma. Maybe they nodded off at the time of the accident they were driving. Tremendous psychological stress. Maybe they were sexually abused. or whatever, that rewires their brain. So now they come in and the pain pattern doesn't fit. We do physical stressing of their various tissues and the reactions, they change their variable.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They're not what they should be. The way that their brain perceives the pain has been rewired. If we give them the traditional approach of giving them more fitness and ability, it won't work. We can't break through that maladaptive response. We completely change. Now it might be just to desensitize them. You'll laugh at this. We might get a feather and brush it over their back.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And they'll say, oh, yeah, that triggers my pain. Really? Yes. Oh, now I'm getting a headache. Okay. So we have to come up with what can they do without triggering that maladaptive response. And it might be that. Simply, the most simple of movements where the afferent and efference, all the information going into that engram, which is formerly triggering pain, we now trigger.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
figure out what it is that doesn't trigger pain, and then slowly desensitize it with repetition, never triggering pain, and then we expand that repertoire. So you've heard of fibromyalgia, which is a little bit of a catch-all term, but a flashing light surprising someone. They're walking down the street and someone comes out of a shop and surprises them somehow.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And that triggers off this massive pain response. We do that with very gentle love, doing the things that doesn't cause pain and try and slowly expand that engram into a pain-free one. There are those in what's called work hardening. It's usually funded by insurance companies. If you have intransigent back pain, we are now going to get you to do your job. We start out with an hour a day.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You're a bricklayer, you're going to lay bricks for an hour. Tomorrow, you're going to lay for an hour and a half. occasionally they have some success or they have some really miserable failures. And the person says, I cannot do another day of bricklaying for four hours, even though it's only a portion of my job. And so now they get kicked out of the program because they're called a non-compliant.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
In other words, there's something psychological wrong with them and they're shattered. Those are the people we see. So these are, you know, talk about the biopsychosocial approach. I know I get labeled sometimes as the biomechanist and I ignore all the psychosocial, but these are people who've never read our work and they don't know.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So I really appreciate you bringing this because I'm not often asked this perspective. But again, I know with your background, you'll appreciate all of this.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Genetics loads the gun, exposure pulls the trigger, and then the psychosocial milieu around the individual influences how they respond to the pain. So there's a start. We can break it down in those three categories if you wish.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You're right in that I haven't seen good science to back up this whole issue. But after working with people for 40 years and seeing the extremes of the phenotype and I do have some opinions on this. And it comes from coaching. So if you take an athlete who has, by nature, they're very explosive neurologically. They're quick. They're explosive. But they can't do it for very long.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It's almost, and I hate using this label, but it's just a way to describe it. They have attention deficit. Now, I've been told I have this. Every high school teacher would have told you, yeah, McGill, his attention deficit is... Now, maybe it was just I wasn't interested in what they were talking about. My brain was thinking about something else.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But I think I do have a certain degree of attention deficits. If someone's not holding my attention, I'm thinking of something that's more important. The more explosive the athlete is, the shorter the time you have to coach them, that they're present with you. The less explosive they are, the more time you have to coach them. So I will say that.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Can I go with a little anecdote there that you may appreciate? I'll get a call from a coach, say an NBA coach, and it'll be with their medical staff. And they'll say, we have this player, they play 18 minutes a game. Can you help? And they have a back pain history. Could you help us to get them to play 27 minutes a game? And then I'll investigate and understand the player.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then I may ask a question to the coach. What puts paying bums in the seats in the stadium? And they'll say, well, what do you mean? And I said, well, it's that player that we're talking about. That player is magical for the 18 minutes that they play because they're sparky, they're explosive.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If we train them and they have a plastic physiology and neurology that we can train so that they can last 27 minutes, you realize that you're trading off the explosiveness. you cannot have a really high VO2 max and be maximally explosive. They're competing mechanisms. One's a fast twitch mechanism for speed and explosiveness. And the other one is an endurable physiology.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And you trade one for the other. So do you really want to compromise that explosiveness And you see this when you're on a team getting a combat athlete ready. If they are neurologically explosive, you design the fight and the training that they pretty much have to win in the first round. And if they don't win in the first round, they're going to gas out.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And the person who is preparing to compete against them is training to survive the first round. And then come on in the second. So they're training endurance. To compare those two different athletes from a psychological point of view, and if you do it enough, I think you'll come to agree with me. And you will notice that there is how you coach them. It has to be in short, consumable bites.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And it's not that they're any more or less intelligent. They get it. but you have to be on cue and choose your words, be efficient. Do you see what I mean? The coaching style changes quite a bit.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It depends and it's a dance. So I can give you some examples. One chapter in my back mechanic book is called, well, it's about surgery and should you have surgery? We did this because as you know, in our experimental clinic at the university, we followed up with every patient we ever saw. We would assess them, and then we would subcategorize them into different bins.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If a person was told, you've tried everything, you've been to the chiropractor, you've been to the physical therapist, the osteopath, you've had a surgical consult, you've been to the psychologist, et cetera, and you failed every single one of them. So basically, you've been conditioned to fail. We tried a process called virtual surgery. So I'm defining the group now.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You've tried everything and you've been told the last thing for you is surgery. That's the subcategory of people that we're now going to talk about. And I'll say, fine, you can go and roll the dice and have surgery. Most of them don't want it, obviously. And I'll say, but what we're going to do is try virtual surgery. And I make a bit of a production out of it. I anoint them like a knight.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I touch them on the shoulder and I say, that's your surgery. And I'm looking into their eyes. And now I give them one of these. We're looking into each other's soul now. You've had surgery. You're going to behave like you've had surgery. Tomorrow, your first post-surgical recovery day, you're going to lay in bed, relax, get up for a pee every two or three hours, have short little shuffles.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
The next day, we'll add a little bit more, et cetera. We give you a post-surgical recovery program, a really good one. And then we start tuning the body strategically, stability, mobility, eventually adding a little bit of endurance long before strength, and then getting the movement patterns, et cetera.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If the person was an exercise addict as well, so you can imagine the person who has the personality that you're describing. They tell me in the interview, you know, I have to ride the elliptical for 40 minutes every day because if I don't, I'm going to murder my kids and my husband because that's my stress relief. Not literally, but that's what they'll say as painting the picture.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Right. Or exercise. Okay. So they've won that negotiation with every previous clinician. Well, they're not going to win it with me because all I care about is outcome. My job is to get them better. by whatever means. So I have to tame that. Surgery works in a lot of cases because it's forced rest. Surgery for that exercise addict forced them to have rest and allowed them to desensitize.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So we fake it and we do it. Now for the evidence, we followed up with every patient and in a two-year follow-up, 95% of those people who avoided surgery but did the virtual surgery were glad that they did?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
That's an argument that's used a lot. However, as I said, I've done the work and I've done the follow-up, and I have an opinion for a reason. We start out by giving them the tools to not have pain. from a physical point of view, that's really important. From a psychological point of view, we've just empowered that person. They are now in control because they never had the tools.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
A, they didn't understand what the real mechanism of pain was, so they had no strategy to down regulated, if I'm a neuroscientist, or to desensitize it. But now they know with some precision what the moves, the loads, the activities are that cause their pain. They know the counterpoints, what actually are beneficial for their pain, and they begin this life of having as little pain as possible.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Now I go back to the tipping point and all systems need stress. But in the beginning, we cannot cross the tipping point. And that's really the essence of your question. When do we start pushing them now to allow a little bit of pain? Some people start it way too early. We do not.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
We know where that tipping point is, and we keep building the training capacity of being pain-free until we have a margin of safety. Now it's that margin of safety that we start to play with. Can we expand the volume of training and get them ready to go back to work or to go back to their sport? Or maybe they just want to play recreational golf. We've talked about that.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Eventually, we're going to go to the point where we're butting up against the tipping point now. Now we have another conversation. Remember what the goal is. How important is it for you to set a personal best and deadlift or to play 18 holes of golf five days a week? Would you settle for three? And now they've had a year of no pain. Their life has changed. They're mentally in a different place.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They have their answer and they converged on it themselves. I'm not 18. I'm 55 years of age. I've got two young grandkids. I'm looking forward to playing golf with them when I'm 75. So do you see how when we bring them through that way, accepting a certain amount of pain, that's more of a younger person's outlook. There's still some warriors left. A lot of us soften up as we get older.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But, you know, I just think of my own journey. I trained... heavy as a kid. And I remember my dad saying, well, why are you doing this? You're really shortening your athletic career. Not that I had one, but you know. And he was right. And now my training has totally changed. But as you know, I have no pain. I'm still fairly physical.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You don't have the capacity to push now. If I go into pain, I'm in pain for a few days, not an hour. So you're cautious. Yeah. And older people will get to that point.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Okay. So they've got mechanical back pain. They've got neurological involvement if it's shooting down the leg. How old are they? Early 50s, maybe in their 40s or older. Okay. It's a big range. So they will have some discogenic disorder. There's a disorder of the joint and it will be causing the nerve to react in such a way.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Ah, okay, so they have a younger spine because discogenic disorders are more common among younger people and sitting is the causative pathway, going for a walk is the relieving pathway, but that will switch over when they get older. Is that right? Yeah, sitting becomes the relief and walking then becomes the exacerbator of their pain. Well, again, I need to know with some precision
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
what the pathway is. But if they have neurological parts, I need to know why, what makes them worse. So I might have them sit upright in a chair, grab the seat pan of the chair and pull up. I'm adding compression. Does that cause more nerve radiation? If it does, they've got a little bit of compression intolerance. Okay, so now I have to choose an exercise that is not compressive by nature.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If I move the nerve, so if I extend their leg at the same time, ask them to look up, it releases the whole spinal cord and all the nerve roots from above and it pulls it from below. In other words, it flosses it through. If that causes pain as they're doing it, they've got nerve friction. If they do it and it's tensile tension, then it's nerve tension.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So these are very different mechanisms of their pain and they require different approaches. So do you see why I'm still hedging on that next exercise that might be mobilizing the nerve, it might be giving them more thoracic spine extension through a thoracic. And now they've taken the load off when they sit and stand.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
My thought would not go to one or the other, but it would go to both. And I'd start that conversation with this analogy. Let's talk about breeds of dogs. We both love dogs. If I said to you, we're gonna take two dogs and we're gonna train them for the Greyhound track. One's a Greyhound and one's a St. Bernard. How do you think you're going to make out? The St.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So you can imagine standing, you can palpate your erector spinae muscles and they might be relaxed. You poke your chin and those muscles come on. But the cramp was on one side and if it was muscular, that's probably not related to this. That's still a very discogenic sign. There's a bulge or there's something off that's mechanical that we will determine.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I might just say, walk more, but not in a single dose. And again, I've described all of this in Back Mechanic. Instead of walking an hour in one dose, have three 20 minute walks. Walking for an hour, Increase the risk of getting pain. Walking for 20 minutes, guaranteed you have no pain. So do it in three doses. You've just guaranteed success.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So I might add another exercise, but I might program it very strategically as well.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Right. Well, again, if you follow our work, we do do deloading of the spine through traction. It's usually applied by one of our trained clinicians. And the reason for that is let's take that younger person again, as you just described, maybe laying on their tummy.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
As they exhale, they allow the low back to sink into the table, increasing the lordosis, which is, we measured this in the lab, if they have a posterior disc bulge with an open fissure, which is probably one of the more common ones, the... that maneuver vacuums in the disc bulge.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If that immediately reduces the pain down their leg, I would say lay prone and have someone pull on your legs along the plane of the table, five or six pounds per leg. Now, the next person comes in and say, oh, that hurts. Well, now we play what we call jazz. This is the art of therapy. I'm playing with how we're going to apply a twisting torque to their feet.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
No decompression table does all of this. It doesn't have the art. It's more of a brutal hammer. And to really get difficult people, because remember, no one has back pain and says, oh, I think I'll go see Miguel. It doesn't work that way. we only get the ones who've failed 10 previous attempts.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
No, we've got to know, we've got to have some skills here.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
That's exactly what you should feel. So you've improved the cylinder. So the diaphragm pumps up and down inside the cylinder to allow you to lung ventilate. If you don't have that athletic diaphragm, you're entraining your abdominal muscles, the oblique muscles, to the breathing effort while you're running. It wears you out. It also compromises your spine.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So you need those muscles to form a girdle and hold it all together. Now, I know enough of your history that I suspect you will have a little bit of a disc bulge.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
vacuuming in of certain types of disc bulges. So I'm glad it works for you and you found it and it will work for some others or it will make the pain worse than some others. And there's tests for figuring that out.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Bernard, no matter how you train it or condition it, will never make it to the performing on a Greyhound track. You're gonna end up with a broken St. Bernard. So there's a little bit of a start from my big perspective, but now let's drill down and talk about spines. It's interesting when you look at the basic anatomical structure of an individual. We just did that with dogs.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
if they're a student, travel with it, sitting in a restaurant. People who go and say, oh, my back's killing me after sitting in that booth in the restaurant.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I'm past the funny looks. I'm okay with that.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I'm with you 100% with the notion that walking is one of the most healthy things you can do. I get stuck a little bit when you want me to give numbers in a generic broad application. Ranges are fine. If I saw the person, and they have a back pain history, I would know, A, should I just leave walking alone and tell them to walk? It's quite fine.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
That's not your problem, but we still want you to walk three or four times a day. But I know what the question is, and you want some general rules on all of this. Don't walk to pain. So if your tipping point is 40 minutes, you can't go and for a 40-minute walk. You've just guaranteed that you will be unsuccessful in having a pain-free day. But can you walk 20 minutes? Good.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Walk 20 minutes three times a day. Now you've got a full hour of pain-free walking guaranteed. So it was the exposure and how you dosed it throughout the day. If the person has discogenic back pain, they will find that they don't like to stand in one position for very long, sit in one position for very long, or do any single activity for a long period of time.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So the key for their daily regimen is to keep changing posture. So something like a sit-stand desk at work would be a really good idea. But now the magic comes if they could sit for 20 minutes, stand for... 30 minutes and walk for 10. Now that was the magic of the dosing that allows them to do their job as a computer programmer or whatever it is where they're a slave to the computer.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
There's no option. So there's an idea there. In my own life, it's a habit. I walk after every meal. I walk before I go to bed and that's my time with my wife and my dog and it's our routine. And it is, even when we travel in the winter, we drive south, we break up the drive and we do our walks and it keeps us pain-free. It doesn't matter who you are.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If you sit all day, chances are you will cause pain. I can talk about damage, which is interesting. We've probably loaded more spines than any other laboratory in the world. I think that's a fair thing to say. If we put a cadaveric spine, that is what we call a virgin spine. In other words, it came from a young donor, it wasn't traumatized, so there's no preexisting cumulative damage to it.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If you put it in a sitting posture, you cannot create new injury. So if a person has never had back pain, and I can give you an example. You know the person that they're probably overweight, And all they do is sit. It's so unfair. They don't have any back pain. And then their colleague is much more fit. They go to the gym every day. They have back pain, and they think this is so unfair.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Imagine if I took a thin willow branch. I could bend that willow branch back and forth over and over and it wouldn't accumulate stress. But if I took that same willow branch and loaded it top to bottom like an I-beam, It would just bend and break. So it supports bending cycles, but it doesn't support compression. Now I'm going to change that willow branch into a thicker stick.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But what they didn't realize is they are not training wisely at the gym. They are probably going far too hard in a short period of time with too much intensity, and they're creating a little bit of microtrauma. So now they just made sitting painful. So do you see what I mean? You can't injure the spine sitting if you have no pre-existing injury.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But if you have pre-existing delamination of the collagen, an old disc bulge, sitting for a long time will then make it painful.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Okay. Those who know me know it could be any of those three options. At the highest level, Every exercise is a tool and it's a tool to reach a specific goal.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So in our world of limited capacity, when a person is fresh coming out of back pain or they're training to really achieve something physically, have they defined the goal and have they chosen the best tool to keep as much capacity as they can for training other things that really matter? The deadlift is an extraordinary exercise.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And as you know, I don't know of anyone who's been involved with more world-class deadlifters than myself through the back pain relationship. So, you know, on one hand I can say, well, I love the deadlift. And on another hand, I can say, I hate the deadlift. I can tell you, Andrew,
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
that if you take the clients who ask for consults now and they're under 30 years of age, I will say half of them will say in their interview with me, it started with a deadlift. So I would say that is getting onto the category of an epidemic. And yet I will still tell you, I love the deadlift. So there's a lot of variables here, a lot of moving parts. The deadlift,
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
is a tremendously neurologically dense exercise. Whether you're lifting a light weight or a heavy weight, I love these bodybuilding charts that say, oh, well, to do a deadlift, it lights up the erector spinae, the glutes, and the quads, perhaps. Every single muscle of the body should be involved at a deadlift. Every single muscle. There are no agonists and antagonists.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Every muscle, the full fascial complex, will be tightened up to take the slack out to pull a bar from the ground. That's a good deadlift. That's what minimizes the risk of injury. And as you know, competitive deadlifters will actually put on a exoskeleton of even more fascial stiffness. It's called a lifting suit. But not everybody, obviously, is in that category.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Now I'm going to talk about one of the most potent pathways to disc herniation. So we have the disc from an anatomical point of view, it's a gel core wrapped with layer upon layer, concentric layers of collagen fibers.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
that in order to get a disc bulge or a disc herniation, they needed to delaminate and the gel nucleus, when it's pressurized under a heavy bend, will seek the weak spot between these fibers, work through the delamination and create a disc bulge. There's been several recent studies now that have done assays, investigations of the harvested nucleus in a disc surgery.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And I bend the stick once and it shatters. In other words, the... Thickness and radial diameter being larger means the stress is bigger in bending. However, let's compress the same stick. It can bear tremendous compression. So there's a very fast example on spines. There's a fellow who has the world record in consecutive sit-ups, thousands of them.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
More than half the time, that harvested nucleus contained fragments of broken end plate. Broken end plate comes from excessive compression. And then you go into the history of the person. Oh, well, maybe they fell on ice and they piledrived their back. There's a candidate mechanism to create small fractured bits of end plate.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But then they will say, no, this whole disc herniation story, it started with a deadlift. Two years ago, my back got a bit tweaky after that. I kept deadlifting and whatnot. And then they find the fragments of bone. So more than half of that harvested nucleus shows evidence of an overload and compression. When you put that together with the history, and again, it's not the fault of the deadlift.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It's the fault of the deadlift. progression. There are some trainers who will take a person from an unfit state through to lifting in a deadlift twice their body weight in half a year. When you look at the stimulus to bone growth, it takes a lot longer than half a year. And when you look at the characteristics of really successful deadlifters, they're not young men and women.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They are people who've trained their body over many years to get that density of bone because that really is the weakest link in a deadlift as far as back injury goes. So there's something to consider, first of all. Let's go back to the back pain person now. And there are some people who do not perform an assessment and they say, oh, if you've got back pain, the symptom of back pain do deadlifts.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, hold on a second. One of the first things we do after we've assessed them is to try and get rid of the cause that almost always involves teaching them how to bend at the hips and not stressing and creating concentrations in the spine. It's called the hip hinge.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Then we may put a load in their hands, and then we have to assess their hips to determine whether the hips have shallow sockets or deep sockets. In other words, what's the hip range of motion that will allow you to pick a bar off the ground? There are many people who shouldn't be picking heavy bars off the ground.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
When you look at the size of an Olympic, I call them cookies, but a 45-pound plate, I suppose, that was arbitrarily chosen. In fact, it was actually chosen that if someone dropped the bar on the ground, your head could fit between the bar and the ground. That was where that original size of the cookie came from, is my understanding of it. People lifting alone quite often, is that why? Oh, yeah.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Yeah. Well, there's lots of YouTubes of those injuries. But anyway.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Right. So now we've put together the idea of what – anatomy do they have in the hips and where's the tipping point in picking something off the ground? We may start to progress the hip hinge into a loaded situation if the person doesn't have compressive load triggers to their back pain pattern. I doubt we'll be pulling a bar off the ground, though. We will elevate the bar and put it on blocks.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So if you come to BackFit Pro and you look at our rack that has 1,300 pounds there available to lift if you wish, they pull off pins. In other words, we're matching the height of the pull to their biomechanical optimum in the beginning. And then we have to decide... Is the deadlift the best tool to get them to their goal?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Given what I've just said, what's your prediction? Do you think he has a big strong fellow with a thick spine? Or do you think he's a very slender man with a willowy thin spine?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You know, I did the podcast with Peter Attia and Peter had a little section on the deadlift and he asked me the same question, but he just told me his personal story of conflict and whether he should be deadlifting. You know, he's had a couple of spine surgeries as a younger man when, you know, none of us knew better in those days, I suppose.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And my answer was to him, and a lot of people took it, and we got a lot of blowback on this, that it was a generic answer for deadlifts. And it wasn't. It was an answer for him where I started to talk about, well, maybe for yourself, why don't we walk backwards up a hill in a monster walk style, and you will feel the quads burning. How many squats and deadlifts do you really need to do?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then urology comes into this. You walk backwards up a hill, say it's about 50 yards. Your quads are burning. Then walk down to the bottom of the hill and walk forwards up the hill. The brain says, I'm perceiving exhausted quads. Let's go get the next in the hierarchy, your glutes. It's a fabulous stimulator to glutes. So there you go.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I've just found a better tool for a person who has limited capacity. Deadlift was not the way to go. They're going to walk backwards uphill and then they're going to walk forward and really feel tremendous exhaustion if that's how they get their jollies and if that's what we need in the athleticism to keep them going and building robustness.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Bingo. He has to be. There's no option. So there's a start on the genetics. Not everybody can play offensive tackle and not everybody can be a gymnast or not everybody can simply tolerate sitting in a chair being a computer operator.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It's exactly the same answer that I gave you for deadlifts. A, it depends, and B, is it the best tool to reach the goal? That is an auxiliary exercise. It's not a deadlift. It's just challenging a part of the chain involved in the full chain that's required for a deadlift.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If I go back to some of the criticism after that original deadlift statement, there was a lot of older fellows who were saying, you know, I love the deadlift. When I stop deadlifting, my back pain actually increases and deadlifting keeps the bogeyman away. I get it. Okay, that was the right tool for them. But I can tell you about the characteristic of those people.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They will be somewhat unidimensional in their athleticism. I will bet you dollars to donuts. Actually, donuts are getting more expensive now. So that's a poor analogy. That worked when I was a kid. But anyway, ask them to throw a football. Ask them to swing a golf club. I'll bet you the ones who say deadlifts are good for their back pain won't do well in either of those activities.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
A deadlift is not a pulsing strength. It's a grinding strength. And again, if you want neurology, To adapt, to create, you know, again, I know people don't like when I do this, but when I, I like athletic examples and I learned so much because it's like a car mechanic working on a McLaren car. And then a dump truck, which carries heavy load.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then a Baja racer, which is incredibly endurable because it shows you, in terms of engineering and automotive technology, what is possible. So when you work with a great athlete, you learn what is humanly possible. So something like a deadlift, it teaches the nerves to carry electricity. When you measure a very good deadlift, it is an exhausting process. But think of it, what is strength?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Strength starts with this thought and now you have to densify that thought. Then you have to densify the pulse train down through the nerves and you've got to teach the nerves to carry that amount of electrical pulse. Then you've got to teach the muscles to utilize it. So in terms of grinding strength capacity, a deadlift is pretty good, but does that have to do with most people with back pain?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
A few years ago, the professional golf community led by a few personalities, got into heavier lifting. Now, this was rather odd. If you go back to the old days of Jack Nicklaus and Gary Player and Arnold Palmer, do you think they lifted heavy weights? And I think Arnold Palmer is still playing.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But my point is, the more you deadlift, the less you will be able to throw a football and play golf. So if your goal in life is to be generally able to enjoy a really diverse array of activities, be careful on the tools that you choose.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So going back to the pro golfers of say 15 years ago, when a few of them got into Olympic lifting, which is heavy hip mobility down to the deep squat for the snatch and tremendous shoulder mobility and deadlifts. Not one of them, to my knowledge, and I know some of them intimately well, hit the ball further. But they ended up with sore knees and disc bulges.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Essentially, really heavily compromising their careers. And then a few of them, and I've worked with quite a number of them, have now backed off that heavy lifting. And they have less pain, far more resilience. And I think they're going to be playing a lot longer for it. So I know that's going to create some controversy, but so be it.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If you want, first of all, I don't put you in the category of high risk for osteoporosis, which is mineral loss from your bones through genetics and way under the tipping point in terms of load stimulation. So I'm not worried about that for you. So if I was, that would justify a heavier loading regimen for now. But as alternatives, a rear leg elevated split squat.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You can do it just with body weight or consider this, interlace your fingers, put them behind your head, become a peacock, lift your chest up. Now do the split leg rear elevated squats, like lunge squats. And you're potentiating the erector spinae and the whole stabilizing mechanism by pushing up and resisting.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Now, do you see how that just stimulated your whole upper body? And the more you push and the more you- Metal traps, everything lined up.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You just lit up your whole erector spinae. We did all of that without a heavy bar. You could do a goblet squat, hold it in front. Now the whole body takes a more upright attitude. It's more knee load if you want more knee load and less back and hip load, or a back squat, you add more hip and low back load and you take some off the knees. So you can band the knees.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
We can really play jazz on this to optimize the best variant to get optimal reward with minimal risk. And that will change as you recover from the back injury. It will change with age. It will change with other comorbidities. Oh, my neck's a bit sore. You've dinged up your shoulder or whatever the case may be. Single leg step-ups. would be another example. Now you've added a balance challenge.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
As you get older, your risk will not be mitigated by deadlifts because the biggest risk as you get older is falling. That will really change your life as it does in many people. Do you have the agility and neural dexterity that when you stumble, can you get your foot out ahead of the center of mass, which is now ahead of the base of support? So you're going to fall. You got to get that quick.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So it's hip power, quick. Rest the fall. and really mitigate against catastrophe, which is that fall. So do you see how that changed? But can I just finish off with one thing? And I wanna talk about deadlifts and capacity as well. And again, it's a lesson that we learn from elite athletes.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
When we have an athlete whose goal it is to set a world record, be it in deadlifting or squatting or whatever, they can't train maximum deadlifts and squats two or three times a week. it is just too exhausting. And the recovery period required between training sessions becomes so long, they actually lose the peak off the training progress. So we do it through auxiliary exercise.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So when I think of someone like Brian Carroll, you know, again, this is all sort of content validity types of arguments. I get it. But until someone produces a few more winners, I'm going to stick with the way our science has shown to go. If you train and really push, you know, you're talking about training at 85%, well, are you going to set the world record if you only train at 85%? Probably not.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But if you go to 100%, you've got to take a couple of weeks off. So instead, you do some auxiliaries like Brian used heavily the belt squat machine, which you can really train hips, legs, et cetera. Tremendous power. But it doesn't take or exhaust the whole upper body and back system. Where you're not loading the spine or compressing the spine. That's right. Because you just can't do it.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So do you see why... It's very difficult for me without knowing the person, knowing what the goals are, knowing what their future risks are. Is it a bone mineral density issue or is it their knees are getting a bit cranky now or whatever? I have to choose the most efficient tools. Occasionally, it's a deadlift.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But I also told you that right now, there's too many young people influenced by social media who are trying to set, oh, I'm gonna set a personal best in deadlift, not really knowing how to densify the neural drive, take out all the slack. So when they grip the bar, the final squeeze of the bar actually gets the bar moving.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They're breaking it from the floor with, they're so stiff throughout their body and they don't know this yet. And they end up with a back injury. And those are long lasting. They're hard to recover from.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It is the underlying philosophy of how I train now. It wouldn't have appealed to me when I was in my 20s and 30s. In those days, it was all about strength, power, looking good, impressive, etc., But, you know, my joints aren't what they used to be. My training has evolved with my age.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So the name training, biblical training week, came from the idea that every major religion has a Sabbath day, a day off. And when I was a kid and working with my dad, you didn't do any work on Sunday. And that was his day of allowing all the cumulative work during the week to adapt and settle out. So it's a very wise thing to do. There's six days to train.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
In its basic form, two days a week, I strength train. Two days a week, I work on the things that are a bit sticky and not moving very well because I'm getting older and I have a few injuries. So those are the mobility days. Two days a week, I work on my ticker, cardiovascular system, things to challenge my heart, et cetera. There's more caveats to all of this.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So I live in a rural setting most of the time We heat our cabin. I live in most of the days of the week by wood. So I have to split firewood. If I split firewood, I've checked all the boxes. It's cardiovascular training, it's mobility training, and it's strength training. So it's also a lot of power. So I've done my training for that particular day, but I wouldn't split wood two days in a row.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I wouldn't strength train two days in a row. I wouldn't mobility train two days in a row. So that's another caveat. Don't do the same thing two days in a row and allow the soreness to really develop into something. Another thing that suits me well is routine. I try and go to bed at the same time, get up at the same time. So those are the basic tenets of the biblical training week.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
The components of each, you know, I've had some neck trauma, some shoulder trauma. I broke my hip, I'm hip replaced. These are the things that I focus on for strategic mobility. The strength training is a little bit of bodybuilding, a little bit of strength in patternings. So patterns of a squat, a lift, a lunge, a push, a pull, etc.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And so I don't run because of my hips, but in the summertime, I will swim, kayak, and canoe, but I'll put a bit of beef into it, a bit of effort. I ride my bike. In the winter, I cross-country ski. Shovel snow is a big part where I live, etc., So those are the, oh, by the way, I do do the big three, six days out of seven. And I didn't really discuss that of why they're essential.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
We didn't invent those exercises, but we measured, we were one of the few groups in the world who actually measured spine stability in a quantitative way. Doing the big three was the most efficient way to guarantee spine stability, but spare the spine while you're doing it. Well, some people will say, well, why are you sparing your spine?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It allows me to have capacity, the limited capacity, to do other things. So why would I waste them all on core training? The other thing is we live in a linkage. So the spine is a flexible rod. There's no coincidence that either end of your core is a ball and socket joint, the shoulder and the hips.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If I wanted to push you or an object, a heavy door perhaps at the university or at a shopping mall, say I could bench press 300 pounds. Well, I can't anymore, but say I could. The bench press muscle is the pec major. Let's look at the architecture of the pec major. The pec major crosses the shoulder joint, distal to the shoulder joint, to where it connects on the upper arm bone, the humerus.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Absolutely, yeah. So the knee width, the bialio-crystal width, which is the width of your iliac crests, hip width are all surrogates to indicate general heaviness of the skeleton. So yes, that's one good marker. But there's more to the story for genetics and how bendy a spine can be. The shape of the disc matters.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
The muscle contracts and creates the desired push. But proximal, it connects to my rib cage. Look what it does. It collapses my torso into my shoulder, which is an energy leak. That is anti-push. But if I can use core control and core stiffness and lock down proximally, 100% of that muscle activity now goes distally to the athleticism.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So you may have heard the expression, a stronger core makes you stronger throughout your body. Well, how does that work? I've just explained to you that when you create proximal control and stiffness, it directs the athleticism distally. If you want to wiggle your finger quickly, you had to stiffen your wrist. If you want to wiggle your arm quickly, you had to stiffen your upper arm, etc.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So the mother of all proximal stability is your core. In exactly the same way, a heavy equipment operator using a backhoe, the first thing they do is they put down the stabilizers, which are posts that go into the ground and lift the tires off the ground to stabilize the tractor so that now the arm can be the athlete pulling earth. Failure to stabilize, you're just pulling the tractor around.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So core stability is essential for ability and performance. It's... arresting all little micro movements. We're all shrinking. You will notice this probably over the next decade. The disc height is now shrinking and there's going to be a little bit more micro movement in the discs.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Yes. It will increase disc height for 15 minutes. and then gravity and the hydrostatic pressures will cause the fluid flow. And the fluid flow, there's a little bit through laterally through the disc, but most of it comes through the end plates. So from the vertebral body, into the nucleus of the disc, and you can draw fluid in under tension.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But the hydrostatic pressure overrides the osmotic pressure in gravity, and then the discs lose all the fluid. So it's a 15-minute effect.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I haven't seen any evidence of PRP doing so. Mm-hmm. Now, I didn't condemn PRP throughout the body. I swear by it for stubborn muscle tears in one example. Ball and socket articular joints. There's no question. Not all the time, but it can make a measurable difference, but not injected into the disc. So I just need to give a little bit of a context to this now.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If we take someone's disc who's never been traumatized, so they're a young person... they can expose their spine to mobility, be it yoga or ballet or whatever, and they will probably increase the range of motion and mobility. They can strength train and toughen the collagen in the end plate and build some bone. And in other words, they can do both, Andrew.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They can increase the constituent strength of the various parts and they can create mobility. But once you have an injury to the disc and you lose a little bit of disc height, the world changes. It's not so easy to adapt those full range of athletic abilities anymore. So now you're forced to make a compromise. Most people, we can get them to do one or the other.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
They can maintain mobility to play golf after a disc injury, or they want to pop up on a surfboard. That's their thing in life. They just want to be able to surf. I'll say, good. We can... manage, it's no longer adapting.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
We can manage you to achieve that, but you're gonna have to back off the deadlifts and some of the strength exposures because they will just further compromise the disc height of a damaged disc. And we can do the opposite. If you want to strength train and bear a load, you're going to have to give up the mobility. So that game, that dance with the devil, that comes after the back injury.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So if you take, on average, a group of top golfers, you'll notice that their spines, that the disc shape, if we were to cut through, which is a transverse scan on an MRI, the discs are more ovoid. if you take someone who can bear a lot of compressive load, the discs look more like a lima bean, and that's called a limacon-shaped disc.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So I think the question was a little bit about adaptation. If you haven't experienced disc damage yet, you have a lot more leeway to adapt your spine. After that, it becomes a game of management and encouraging an athletic ability. You become a little bit more unidimensional. And if you want a little bit of everything, okay, but you have to be very modest. You just have to...
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
try and achieve sufficient mobility, sufficient strength to do whatever, just to get through life. And it's a bit of a dance. So I don't know if that gives a bit of a context. That's perfect.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Right. Okay. So let's say today I'm going into our clinic gym, and I will start with doing the big three. So I will do bird dogs, and I'm going to work on good form, and then I'm going to put some dynamicism into it. I don't lift the leg so much. I push the heel away, and it really –
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
causes you to lock the core to create the proximal stability, and then pushing the heel away really engages the glutes and hamstrings. Then I draw small squares. I square out with the hand and foot, down towards the midline and up. So now I'm creating a little bit of a disassociation through the ball and socket joints with I want, which is what I want, with the core control.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So that is translatable. We did an experiment with the Pensacola Fire Department, by the way, where those firefighters who were trained with a coach who explained why they were insisting on certain exercise forms- We measured them doing fire ground tasks before the training sessions.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
In other words, we measured them putting up a fire ladder, advancing a loaded fire hose, which is a tremendous reactive push, as you know. Piking open an elevator door, chopping a hole in a burning roof. Then half of the group trained with this attention to exercise form, and we explained the principles to them.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then the other half of the firefighters had trainers who were more like cheerleaders, trying to get them to do more reps and encouraging them. Both groups got fit. And then we measured them all again out on the fire ground. Remember now, we never trained them how to do the fire ground tasks. They went back to the fire ground.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Those who trained with the cheerleader types of, oh, just do more reps, had more experience. Known injury markers. Do you know valgal collapse of the knee is a very strong predictor of future risk of ACL injury being one of them. So there would be an example of that. Sagittal plane spine motion under load.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I mean, every study that surveils groups who have to bend down through their spine and pick up more load has a much higher incidence. Bill Maris' study showed 10 times the risk factor to having a disc injury. if you do that. So I will then do side planks, rolling side planks.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I will do a variety of abdominal exercises, the modified abdominal curl that you're familiar with, and I'll do some glute bridges. Then I'll do them one-legged and I'll get the arm involved and cross body. I may put a kettlebell on my belly and do some hip thrusts that way, but a very mindful way. I'm focused my brain on squeezing the glutes, pushing the feet away, et cetera.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Then I will probably stand up and do the strength patterns. So I'll go over and do pushes. Now, consider a pushup, which rather than me load heavy, with a bench press or something like that. I'll do pushups, you know, the clapping pushup where you dynamically explode up, clap, and go down. I'll do a variety of those very dynamic power generating pushes. Then I'll do some pulls.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I probably won't do a row with a barbell, but I'll do an inverted row pulling on a TRX, pronated grip, pulling into hammer grip, power breathing, and exploding. really trying to get some power into it. Then I will go to probably a split lunge, rear elevated foot squat, lunge squat with the techniques that I showed you.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Hands interlaced behind my head, peacocking high, pushing back, pulling forward, and now doing the lunge squat. So that's challenging my balance. the whole extensor chain strength, et cetera. I might do some bilateral squats with my hips. I've broken my ankle. I do heel elevated squats, usually with a banded knee. And sometimes I just use my brain and try and spread the floor.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Then I get into the auxiliaries. So I broke C4. I have to, yeah, not a good thing. Playing football. Hockey. Hockey. Head down into the boards. Classic. Anyway, I can't really do shearing exercises where I push against resistance. That will get my neck a bit cranky. So I take out the shear. I get tall. I push my tongue hard to the roof of the mouth and I grimace.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
So now I've activated all the flexors and I put my hands underneath and I just push up isometrically and I control that. So there's no shear anymore, but I've really started to build the flexor family. Keep your neck strong. It's important for me. Yep. Now put your, your chin poking retract. Now push up. You got it. That's it. Push your tongue. Yeah. Don't go crazy.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And add a little bit of endurance to that.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Because I really enjoy them. If you're a wrestler at University of Iowa, you've been doing it for a good while, you're probably okay doing neck bridges.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Think of every pulling motion. Where does it start? The trapezius originates off the neck. Stack that flagpole and really get those muscles ready to pull. It requires a stiff, strong neck. Absolutely. So every strong puller has that.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Anyway, I'll finish out my strength routine with some more auxiliaries. People laugh at this. I call it sword play. The amount of athletic gain that we've achieved with sword play. I take an iron bar, like the old weeder dumbbell weight. It'll be an iron bar about that long, and I'll put maybe a two-pound weight on the end.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And then I grab it, and I do figure eights over here, over here, over here, around there. You wouldn't believe I have professional hockey players in the NHL who say, wow, those figure eight sword plays, my wrist shot, my slap shot, have tour tennis players. I've never had such power and finesse off the racket because of that sword play exercise.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
May I give you a couple of comments? Please. That was fabulous. It's so much fun when I see someone getting out of their car and walking up to the clinic door. And I can see the muscle wasting on their calf. And they'll say, oh, I have to get out my EMG machine. nerve conduction velocity scores here. I said, are you kidding me?
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You're telling me the doc needed to do EMG conduction velocity and all I had to do was look at your leg? We know exactly the nerve roots that are deficit because I know exactly what serves those muscles that have wasted. I mean... It's crazy how technology has made so many people oblivious to the signs that we all show. That was my first comment.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But the second one was going back to the old time books. I collect a lot of those actually. I have quite a library of the old time strength books, some from the 1800s, the old book of strength and they're fabulous. Indian clubs. Are you familiar with Indian clubs? So it's a wooden club that looks like a bowling pin, basically. But some of the old style Indian clubs were this long.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, there's a great manual strength athlete that not too many people have heard of, John Brookfield. He lives in North Carolina, Pinehurst, North Carolina. In Pinehurst, there's a sculpture of very heavy steel that John bent with his bare hands to make this sculpture with. Yeah, he'll take heavy rebar and bend it and, you know, put on strength shows with his hands.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
He's a fabulous fella too, by the way. I, he's got a set of Indian clubs. I can hardly pick one up, but he just picks up this Indian club. And it was from some famous guy from the 1800s. And somehow he got the Indian clubs and they're about this long, but he could just get them and play sword play with very heavy Indian clubs. There's actually a good friend of mine.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
He's an Australian fellow, Andrew Locke. I don't know if you've ever heard of Andrew Locke. And Andrew has collected kettlebells and Indian clubs from the old timers. He's got quite a lovely collection in Melbourne, where he's from in Australia. But they're wonderful exercises.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Yeah. We evolved discs and there really is no other better architecture. People say, well, why don't we have ball and socket joints in our spine? And the reason is this. Can you imagine stacking five oranges, one on top of the other, and then you could make them mobile by putting a ball and socket joint in between them. The amount of control that you would need on every single orange is
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, simply things, and you can certainly comment about this, I try and do things with my opposite hand. So today I'm just going to brush my teeth, comb my hair with my opposite hand. Now, don't ask me to throw a ball because I'm a moron, but if I'm splitting firewood, okay, 10 reps this way, 10 reps that way.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And that's all in an attempt to keep my brain as movement competent and dexterous as possible.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, if I can convince you to consider the biblical training week, all of that fits into your mobility days.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Well, given my history, I do thoracic spine extension. I do a little bit of neck work, hip mobility. But again, I have a certain capacity there that I can't overdrive. And then once I've done the targeted ones, I just go through the motion of every joint and don't add load. And then I will do the footwork. So with my background, I'll do a little bit of shadow boxing.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
I'll play traditional southpaw, etc.,
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
It depends on the time of year. I really like to be outside. So if it's wintertime and I, for some reason, couldn't go for a cross-country ski that day or whatnot, I will ride a stationary bike in the clinic. I'd prefer not to, but I will. If it's summertime, I'm riding outside. And I could kayak, swim, canoe, just go to the hills and walk with Tico, my dog, hard.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
And that might be my cardiovascular that day. And going back to the genetics, which is how we started this podcast, Have you ever had your athletic panel done from a genetic base? In other words, they look at your genes and determine what you're genetically good at and what you're genetically horrible at. Do you know that? I mean, I know a few things that I'm horrible at.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
But you haven't had it tested genetically? No. Okay. I have. And they gave me a panel of 10 athleticisms. Now, interestingly enough, if I didn't have my athletic panel and you just asked me to check, am I good at this or am I bad at it? And check somewhere in between, I would have got every single one 100% right. Interesting. Yeah. So I know my abilities and it aligns 100%.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
You move one orange, you have to control all the others. It's mission impossible. I would do an experiment with students in my lectures. I would take four coffee cans and put a tennis ball between each coffee can. And then I would put a rope at the front and the back of each coffee can and then one on the side. And I had four students take those four ropes.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
In other words, I'm ultra, which is the highest for grip strength. I always knew that, you know, they're a pair of hands, but if I got my hands on you in football, you weren't getting, you know what I mean? I've always had a very good grip strength. So genetically that came through as ultra. And the other thing I was ultra at was I can be quick for the first 35 milliseconds, boom.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
If you want something done like that, I can usually pop it, you know? When I was playing hockey, typically it's a 45, 50 second anaerobic blast. And you sit down for three minutes, there's two more shifts, and then the coach taps you on the helmet, and I'm still breathing heavily. And my two line mates, they're ready to go again. I was terrible at recovering from an athletic. anaerobic blast.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Guess what? I'm the worst possible genetic category for recovery of heart rate. And I've worked with some of the best heart rate recovery people and I'm hopeless at it.
Huberman Lab
Dr. Stuart McGill: Build a Strong, Pain-Proof Back
Make sure you take that day off. You will be less painful with your joints, I predict, when you're going into your 60s and 70s and knock on wood. having a blast when you're 80.